Revision summary
The 74th Amendment and the Twelfth Schedule create municipalities but leave devolution to State law. Parastatals and State-appointed commissioners keep functions out of the elected council. Property tax is constrained; GST ended octroi and sent compensation to States, not cities. Late State Finance Commissions and approval for borrowing keep cities fiscally dependent. The statement is correct: functional and financial empowerment is still a State choice.
Model answer
Introduction
The Constitution (Seventy-fourth Amendment) Act, 1992, made municipalities a third tier of government and listed 18 functions in the Twelfth Schedule. A comment on State reluctance must show how States still hold those functions, staff, and taxes.
Body
Functional reluctance
- Article 243W leaves it to the State legislature to endow municipalities with Twelfth Schedule functions; the Union cannot force devolution of urban planning, water, fire services, or slum improvement.
- Many States keep parastatal bodies for water, transport, and development authorities, so the elected council does not control the function that the Schedule names.
- Mayor-in-council or a weak ceremonial mayor, plus a State-appointed municipal commissioner, splits political authority from administrative control.
- The State Election Commission and State Finance Commission exist in the text, yet delayed elections, prolonged administrator rule, and delayed SFC reports are common.
- Building-plan, land-use, and police powers remain with State departments even in million-plus cities, which is functional reluctance in daily governance.
Financial reluctance
- Article 243X allows States to assign taxes, duties, tolls and fees; property tax is still the main own tax, and States cap rates, grant exemptions, and delay revision of guidance values.
- Goods and Services Tax absorbed octroi, entry tax, and local surcharges; GST compensation went to State governments, not automatically to city budgets.
- State Finance Commissions under Article 243Y are often late, and State governments do not always accept or notify the award in full.
- Central Finance Commission grants to urban local bodies (Fourteenth and Fifteenth Finance Commissions) are tied to reforms, but they cannot replace a State’s refusal to share stamp duty, entertainment tax residue, or a predictable share of GST.
- Municipal borrowing and municipal bonds need State guarantee or approval, so even a solvent city cannot raise debt on its own balance sheet.
Why the reluctance persists
- MLAs and State ministers treat cities as vote and patronage territory; a strong municipality is a rival power centre.
- The 74th Amendment constitutionalised the form of local government; it did not constitutionalise a minimum share of State tax or a list of exclusive municipal functions.
- A fair comment therefore agrees with the statement: devolution is discretionary, and both function and finance still sit with the State.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD C[74th Amendment Twelfth Schedule] --> S[State legislature] S --> F[Functions held or given] S --> M[Money property tax GST share] F --> U[Urban local body] M --> U
Conclusion
States remain reluctant because the 74th Amendment leaves functions and taxes to State legislatures, and because parastatals and GST have concentrated money above the ward. Urban local bodies will be empowered only when SFCs, property-tax freedom, and Twelfth Schedule functions are actually transferred, not only listed.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
Discuss the role of Presiding Officers of state legislatures in maintaining order and impartiality in conducting legislative work and in facilitating best democratic practices.
Next question on this syllabus topic (2023 · Q5). View answer →
-
Did GST abolish municipal taxation entirely?
No. Property tax, some user charges, and a few local taxes remain. Octroi and entry tax, which funded many cities, did go into GST.
-
Can the Union devolve Twelfth Schedule functions by itself?
No. Article 243W is addressed to the State legislature. Union grants can only incentivise devolution.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2023 · Q2 · GS II · 10 marks
Who are entitled to receive free legal aid? Assess the role of the National Legal Services Authority(NALSA) in rendering free legal aid in India. -
2023 · Q5 · GS II · 10 marks
Discuss the role of Presiding Officers of state legislatures in maintaining order and impartiality in conducting legislative work and in facilitating best democratic practices. -
2023 · Q7 · GS II · 10 marks
Discuss the role of the Competition Commission of India in containing the abuse of dominant position by the Multi-National Corporations in India. Refer to the recent decisions. -
2022 · Q3 · GS II · 10 marks
To what extent, in your opinion, as the decentralisation of power in India changed the governance landscape at the grassroots? -
2022 · Q6 · GS II · 10 marks
The Gati-Shakti Yojana needs meticulous coordination between the government and the private sector to achieve the goal of connectivity. Discuss. -
2022 · Q8 · GS II · 10 marks
Reforming the government delivery system through the Direct Benefit Transfer Scheme is a progressive step, but it has its limitations too. Comment. -
2022 · Q9 · GS II · 10 marks
India is an age-old friend of Sri Lanka.' Discuss India's role in the recent crisis in Sri Lanka in the light of the preceding statement. -
2022 · Q13 · GS II · 15 marks
While the national political parties in India favour centralisation, the regional parties are in favour of State autonomy." Comment.
More from this topic
Q18 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks
The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights has to address the challenges faced by children in the digital era. Examine the existing policies and suggest measures the Commission can initiate to tackle the issue.
Governance and Policy
Harms: grooming, bullying, addictive design, data profiling, deepfakes, influencer labour, and exclusion without devices. Law: POCSO, IT rules, JJ Act, DPDP 2023 parental consent, NEP caution on ed-tech. NCPCR can inquire, recommend and move courts under the 2005 Act. Measures: age-assurance, school device rules with offline equity, POCSO e-evidence protocol, ed-tech data audits, 1098 integration, influencer-work codes, privacy-by-default for minors. The Commission should regulate design, not become a meme censor.
Q17 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks
"In contemporary development models, decision-making and problem-solving responsibilities are not located close to the source of information and execution defeating the objectives of development." Critically evaluate.
Governance and Policy
The quote names a split: knowledge at the bottom, decisions at the top, execution in between. CSS, SPVs and parallel bodies bypass 73rd/74th institutions that the Constitution empowered. 2nd ARC and Punchhi already diagnosed fragmentation of the local State. The critique fits toilets, housing and MGNREGA planning; it fits less for vaccines, tax and defence. Repair: subsidiarity, untied local finance, elected control of SPVs, shared MIS with the Gram Sabha.
Q15 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks
What are environmental pressure groups? Discuss their role in raising awareness, influencing policies and advocating for environmental protection in India.
Governance and Policy
Environmental pressure groups organise to change ecological decisions of State and firms. Awareness: Chipko, Silent Valley, CSE and climate networks. Policy: EPA, FRA, NGT, EIA contests, PESA and mining consent. Advocacy: Mehta cases, Godavarman, Niyamgiri, Narmada and later climate-rights litigation. Limits: urban bias versus FRA communities, science errors, FCRA chill; they are one constitutional voice, not the ministry.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.