Q6 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2018 · GS II · 10 marks · 3 min read

← Q20 Q9 →

"Policy contradictions among various competing sectors and stakeholders have resulted in inadequate 'protection and prevention of degradation to environment." Comment with relevant illustrations.

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2018
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q6
Marks
10
Topic
Governance and Policy
Syllabus
Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation.

Topic: Governance and Policy. Syllabus: Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2018 and Governance and Policy.

Revision summary

Articles 48A and 51A(g) and a full set of pollution and forest laws already exist. Degradation persists because power, mining, roads, farms and cities run opposite targets. Niyamgiri, corridors versus highways, coal versus air, urea versus aquifers, and Ganga versus sewage are working illustrations. EIA holes and the push for faster clearance widen the gap. A shared landscape limit and Budget conditionality are the way to align stakeholders.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

Article 48A asks the State to protect the environment, and Article 51A(g) asks every citizen to do the same. India also has a thick statute book: the Water Act, 1974, the Air Act, 1981, the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, and the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. Degradation continues because ministries, States, firms and local users pull those laws in opposite directions.

Body

Where the contradiction sits

  • Growth, jobs and energy security are legitimate aims; they become environmental failure when each ministry maximises its own target without a shared ecological limit.
  • The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, and the EIA Notification, 2006, are meant to be the filter; exemptions, post-facto clearances and “linear project” shortcuts punch holes in that filter.
  • The National Green Tribunal Act, 2010, created a specialist forum, yet executive notifications can still shrink what must go to full EIA before a shovel moves.

Illustrations

  • Mining versus forest and tribal rights: bauxite and coal blocks under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act sit on the same land as the Forest Rights Act, 2006. The Niyamgiri (Vedanta) episode showed gram sabha consent blocking a mine that had central clearance on paper.
  • Highways and railways versus wildlife: Bharatmala and freight corridors cut elephant and tiger corridors; compensatory afforestation under CAMPA plants trees elsewhere, which does not replace a corridor.
  • Thermal power and coal versus air and climate: NAPCC and later climate pledges coexist with coal linkages and pit-head plants; cities then use the Air Act and Graded Response Action Plans as emergency medicine.
  • Agriculture versus water and soil: urea subsidy and flood irrigation raise food output and degrade aquifers and soil organic carbon; the same State also funds micro-irrigation and watershed missions.
  • Hydropower and Char Dham-type road widening in the Himalaya versus slope stability and wildlife; disaster then becomes an “act of nature” that policy contradiction had prepared.
  • Coastal Regulation Zone rules versus ports, real estate and aquaculture; State growth lobbies treat CRZ as a delay, not as a storm buffer.
  • River cleaning versus city sewage and hydropower: Namami Gange spends on ghats and STPs while untreated drains and barrages continue, so water quality does not match the scheme photograph.
  • Urban wetlands versus Smart Cities and housing; construction dust and landfill siting fight the Municipal Solid Waste rules that another department notifies.

Stakeholders who do not share one objective

  • Line ministries (power, coal, road, commerce), State industry departments, gram sabhas, forest dwellers, municipal bodies, and courts each hold a legal piece; none holds the whole landscape.
  • The T.S.R. Subramanian Committee (2014) on environment laws sought faster clearance; critics read it as a further tilt toward ease of doing business over the EPA’s precautionary core.

Way forward

  • Make a single landscape-level carrying-capacity plan bind mining, roads and power, instead of project-by-project EIA in isolation.
  • Align the Union Budget: green conditionality on infrastructure grants, and a public dashboard of EIA exemptions.
  • Give Forest Rights Act consent and NGT orders the same political weight as a coal or highway target, or Articles 48A and 21 (as in M.C. Mehta and later clean-air cases) will remain courtroom repairs after the damage.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

  • The comment is fair: India does not lack environment Acts, it lacks one policy spine across energy, mining, farms, cities and forests. Protection will improve when EIA, Forest Rights consent, and sector targets are forced to use the same map, not when another scheme is launched beside a contradictory clearance.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2016 · Q3 · GS II · 12 marks

    "The Indian party system is passing through a phase of transition which looks to be full of contradictions and paradoxes." Discuss.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q15 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

To what extent do pressure groups, social movements and corporate lobbies deepen pluralistic democracy in India by representing excluded interests? Analyse whether the growing convergence of corporate wealth and political power poses a threat to the autonomy of formal democratic institutions.

Governance and Policy

• Pluralism needs many competing groups so that no single interest dominates policy • Trade unions, farmer bodies and movements such as Chipko and Narmada Bachao Andolan have brought excluded voices into public debate • Movements delivered RTI, Forest Rights and Lokpal laws that give citizens lasting tools • Weak resources and FCRA and protest restrictions limit civil society reach • Corporate influence runs through party funding, lobbying, regulators and media ownership • The electoral bonds scheme was struck down in 2024 for violating citizens' right to information • Institutions such as the Supreme Court, CAG and the Election Commission still check capture, but risks remain • Reforms include funding transparency, a lobbying law, cooling-off periods and protection of dissent

Q12 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

What is meant by judicial legislation? In this context, discuss the verdicts of the apex court allowing "passive euthanasia" and a "living will".

Governance and Policy

• Judicial legislation is court-made law that fills a legislative vacuum, using Articles 32, 141 and 142 • Vishaka, Prakash Singh and NALSA are common examples, and each invited later legislation • Gian Kaur (1996) denied a right to die but spoke of dying with dignity when death is imminent • Aruna Shanbaug (2011) permitted passive euthanasia with High Court supervision • Common Cause (2018) held the right to die with dignity to be part of Article 21 and recognised living wills • The 2023 modification simplified attestation, board composition and timelines • The tension is between dignity under Article 21 and the legislature's domain on a sensitive moral issue • A national statute on terminal illness would replace interim court guidelines

Q6 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 10 marks · Solution

Does India's tribal development policy reflect the aspirations for a socially grounded and equity-based governance? Justify your answer.

Governance and Policy

• Constitution: Fifth and Sixth Schedules create tribal self-rule, with Tribes Advisory Councils and autonomous district councils. • Law: PESA 1996 makes the Gram Sabha central and FRA 2006 recognises individual and community forest rights. • Welfare: DAPST, Article 275(1) grants, Eklavya schools, PM JANMAN and the sickle cell mission target the gap. • Weakness: mining, dams and forest clearance rules often override Gram Sabha consent. • Weakness: delayed PESA rules, FRA claim rejections and diverted funds blunt equity. • Security: LWE districts show the cost of land alienation and weak service delivery. • Verdict: strong legal design, uneven delivery, so equity is partial and conditional. • Way ahead: enforce consent, social audit, benefit-sharing through District Mineral Foundations.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free