Q11 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2021 · GS II · 15 marks · 4 min read

← Q15 Q4 →

The jurisdiction of the Central Bureau of Investigation(CBI) regarding lodging an FIR and conducting probe within a particular state is being questioned by various States. However, the power of States to withhold consent to the CBI is not absolute. Explain with special reference to the federal character of India.

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2021
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q11
Marks
15
Topic
Federal Structure and Devolution
Syllabus
Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.

Topic: Federal Structure and Devolution. Syllabus: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2021 and Federal Structure and Devolution.

Revision summary

Police is a State List subject; the CBI enters a State under the DSPE Act, 1946, mainly through Section 6 consent. General consent was the administrative convenience; Andhra Pradesh and West Bengal showed it can be withdrawn, forcing case-specific permission for new FIRs. The power is not absolute: court-ordered probes, Union Territories, and already-attached investigations are not killed by a political letter. Vineet Narain insulated the agency’s working; it did not abolish federal consent. A clear CBI statute would reduce standoffs without pretending India has a U.S.-style dual police sovereignty.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

Police is a State subject; the Central Bureau of Investigation is a Union investigating police that enters a State only through a constitutional and statutory gate. That gate is consent under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946. Federalism explains both why States question CBI FIRs and why their power to withhold consent is not a complete veto.

Body

Federal design and the CBI’s legal basis

  • Entry 2 of the State List puts police with the States; Entry 80 of the Union List allows the Union’s police to extend to a State only with that State’s consent, which is the federal hinge.
  • The CBI traces to the DSPE Act, 1946: it is not a fully independent constitutional police of the kind Article 246 would invent from scratch, which is why States can call it a Union agency on their soil.
  • Vineet Narain v. Union of India sought insulation of the CBI from executive pull, but it did not repeal the consent requirement or convert the Bureau into a federal police with a free run of the Map.

General consent, specific consent, and FIR lodging

  • Section 6 of the DSPE Act requires the State Government’s consent for the CBI to exercise powers in that State; practice grew a ‘general consent’ so every case would not need a fresh letter.
  • Withdrawal of general consent, as Andhra Pradesh and West Bengal did in 2018–20 (with other States at times joining the pattern), means the CBI must seek case-specific consent to register a fresh FIR and investigate inside that State.
  • States argue that without this gate, a Union ministry could plant a police force on a rival State government — a classic federal grievance in a competitive party system.
  • The CBI and the Union argue that corruption in central employees, multi-State crime, and court-ordered probes cannot be held hostage to a State’s political weather.

Why the State’s power is not absolute

  • Consent is not needed in Union Territories, where the Union is the local police authority in the relevant sense.
  • High Courts and the Supreme Court can order a CBI investigation under Articles 32 and 226; judicial federalism then overrides a withheld political consent because fundamental rights and a fair probe are not a State’s patronage.
  • Once a valid investigation has begun, or where the offence is committed in a place already within DSPE jurisdiction, a later political withdrawal of general consent does not automatically kill every pending case; courts have treated abrupt withdrawal as unable to erase jurisdiction already attached.
  • Central employees and specified central offences can still draw the CBI where the statutory notifications and the consent matrix so provide; the State cannot rewrite the Union’s power over its own servants by a press release.
  • The Supreme Court’s federalism cases, including the NCT Delhi line on collaborative federalism, cut both ways: the Union must not treat States as field offices, and States must not treat national investigating agencies as foreign police when the Constitution has already shared the field.

Federal character: a two-sided limit

  • India’s federal character is not dual sovereignty of the U.S. type; it is a Union of States with a strong Centre, a single citizenship, and All-India Services — yet police remains the most sensitive State List entry.
  • A healthy federal bargain is therefore: CBI for complex, inter-State, and court-mandated cases; State police for ordinary crime; consent as a default courtesy, not as a shield for State-level impunity.
  • Recommendation: a comprehensive CBI statute that clarifies consent, mandatory court-monitored probes in specified classes, and a federal crime list, so Andhra/West Bengal-style standoffs are not the only way to argue jurisdiction.

Flow diagram

flowchart TD
  SL[State List police] --> C[s.6 DSPE consent]
  C --> G[General consent]
  G --> W[Andhra WB withdrawal]
  W --> S[Case-specific consent]
  SC[SC HC ordered probe] --> CBI[CBI FIR and investigation]
  UT[Union Territory] --> CBI
  S[S] --> CBI[CBI]

Conclusion

States question CBI FIRs because police is a State subject and the DSPE Act makes consent the federal key. That key is real, as Andhra Pradesh and West Bengal showed by withdrawing general consent, but it is not absolute: court orders, Union Territories, pending jurisdiction, and central subjects still open the door. Indian federalism here is a negotiated police power, not a State veto and not a Union walk-in.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2023 · Q5 · GS II · 10 marks

    Discuss the role of Presiding Officers of state legislatures in maintaining order and impartiality in conducting legislative work and in facilitating best democratic practices.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q13 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

How far has the Indian federal framework been successful in accommodating regional and cultural diversities? Highlight the role of asymmetric federalism and suggest measures to make dispute resolution mechanisms more effective.

Federal Structure and Devolution

• Linguistic reorganisation from 1953 to 1966 gave regional identities an institutional home inside the Union • The Eighth Schedule now lists twenty-two languages and classical language status has widened • The Fifth and Sixth Schedules and Articles 371 to 371J create tailored autonomy for tribal and border regions • Friction continues in language policy, the 2019 changes in Jammu and Kashmir, Manipur and fiscal and delimitation concerns • Asymmetric federalism converts demands into negotiated settlements but needs funds and trust • Dispute machinery includes the Inter-State Council, Zonal Councils, GST Council, tribunals and Article 131 suits • The Inter-State Council meets rarely, and river tribunals are slow • Reforms include a permanent Council secretariat, a single water tribunal, technical panels and mediation

Q11 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Discuss the position of the Governor in the federal polity of India. What is the nature of his power while giving assent to a bill passed by the State Legislature? Is he bound by the aid and advice of his Council of Ministers in all his functions?

Federal Structure and Devolution

• The Governor is the nominal executive head of the State under Articles 153 to 159, appointed by the President and holding office during his pleasure • He links the Union and the State, which gives the office a federal role and a political edge • Article 200 lets him assent, withhold, return a non-money bill, or reserve it for the President • Assent is a constitutional duty guided by legality, not a personal veto, and bills cannot be left pending indefinitely • Recent Supreme Court rulings in the Tamil Nadu dispute and the later Presidential Reference tackled timelines and pocket veto • Article 163 makes aid and advice the rule, with discretion only in narrow express or situational areas • Shamsher Singh and Nabam Rebia limit discretion and make it reviewable • Sarkaria and Punchhi reforms on appointment, tenure and timelines remain relevant

Q14 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Examine the evolving pattern of Centre-State financial relations in the context of planned development in India. How far have the recent reforms impacted the fiscal federalism in India?

Federal Structure and Devolution

Finance Commissions devolve taxes; Planning Commission Plan grants created a discretionary second channel. Sarkaria and Punchhi criticised that discretion. NITI Aayog ended Plan cheques; 14th FC raised the States’ share of the divisible pool to 42%. GST shares tax but limits State rate power; cesses outside the pool and CSS keep Union leverage. Article 293 borrowing conditions remain a hard federal tool.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free