Q4 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2019 · GS II · 10 marks · 3 min read

← Q11 Q1 →

From the resolution of contentious issues regarding distribution of legislative powers by the courts, 'Principle of Federal Supremacy' and 'Harmonious Construction' have emerged. Explain.

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2019
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q4
Marks
10
Topic
Federal Structure and Devolution
Syllabus
Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.

Topic: Federal Structure and Devolution. Syllabus: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2019 and Federal Structure and Devolution.

Revision summary

Legislative disputes are resolved by pith and substance, colourable-legislation tests, and repugnancy analysis. Harmonious construction reads Union and State entries so both retain meaning. If both cannot be obeyed, Article 254 makes the Union Concurrent law prevail. Article 254(2) is a limited, President-assented exception until Parliament occupies the field again. Federal supremacy is the residual rule after harmony fails, not the first strike against every State statute.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

Articles 245 and 246 and the three Lists in the Seventh Schedule divide law-making between the Union and the States. When two laws or two entries appear to clash, the Supreme Court has not always struck one down at once. It first tries to let both live (harmonious construction). If a real conflict remains, Union law prevails (federal supremacy), especially under Article 254 on the Concurrent List.

Body

How courts resolve legislative conflict

  • Pith and substance looks at the true subject of a statute, so a State law is not void merely because it has some incidental Union effect.
  • Colourable legislation asks whether the legislature has done indirectly what the List forbids directly.
  • Occupied field and repugnancy tests apply when Union and State both legislate on a Concurrent entry.
  • These tools came out of cases such as In re C.P. and Berar Motor Spirit, State of Bombay v. F.N. Balsara, and later Hoechst Pharmaceuticals and State of West Bengal v. Union of India.

Harmonious construction of entries

  • Harmonious construction means reading two entries or two statutes so that both have meaning, rather than destroying one by a wide reading of the other.
  • Union and State lists are construed to avoid overlap: a State tax entry is not stretched to cover a Union duty, and a Union entry is not stretched to empty a State field.
  • On the Concurrent List, courts ask whether obedience to both laws is possible; if it is, there is no repugnancy and both operate.
  • The method protects the federal bargain in the Seventh Schedule and matches the idea that federalism is part of the basic structure after Kesavananda Bharati and S.R. Bommai.
  • Harmonious reading is the first duty; supremacy is the residual rule when harmony fails.

Principle of federal supremacy

  • Article 246(1) gives Parliament exclusive power on the Union List; in a direct clash with a State law on that occupied Union field, the Union law stands.
  • Article 254(1) says that if a State law on a Concurrent subject is repugnant to a Union law, the Union law prevails, and the State law is void to the extent of repugnancy.
  • Article 254(2) allows a reserved State law to operate in that State if the President has assented, until Parliament legislates again — a controlled exception, not a denial of supremacy.
  • Federal supremacy here is supremacy of the Constitution’s allocation, usually in favour of the Union when conflict is irreconcilable, not a political claim that States have no lists.
  • Later Goods and Services Tax amendments show the same logic: once a Union-and-State scheme occupies a tax field by constitutional text, State power is read in harmony with that text, not against it.

Short way forward

  • Use pith and substance and harmony first, so cooperative federalism is not killed by a mechanical Union veto.
  • Keep Article 254(2) and Inter-State Council consultation for genuine Concurrent experiments.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

Courts first apply harmonious construction so that Union and State entries both survive. If a true conflict remains, the Principle of Federal Supremacy — Articles 246 and 254 — gives the Union law the last word to the extent of repugnancy, which is how the distribution of legislative powers is kept workable.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2023 · Q11 · GS II · 15 marks

    " The Construction of India is a living instrument with capabilities of enormous dynamism. It is a constitution made for a progressive society". Illustrate with special reference to the expanding horizons of the right to life and personal liberty.

    View answer →

  2. 2022 · Q12 · GS II · 15 marks

    Discuss the essential conditions for exercise of the legislative powers by ne Governor. Discuss the legality of re-promulgation of ordinances by the Governor without placing them before the Legislature.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q13 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

How far has the Indian federal framework been successful in accommodating regional and cultural diversities? Highlight the role of asymmetric federalism and suggest measures to make dispute resolution mechanisms more effective.

Federal Structure and Devolution

• Linguistic reorganisation from 1953 to 1966 gave regional identities an institutional home inside the Union • The Eighth Schedule now lists twenty-two languages and classical language status has widened • The Fifth and Sixth Schedules and Articles 371 to 371J create tailored autonomy for tribal and border regions • Friction continues in language policy, the 2019 changes in Jammu and Kashmir, Manipur and fiscal and delimitation concerns • Asymmetric federalism converts demands into negotiated settlements but needs funds and trust • Dispute machinery includes the Inter-State Council, Zonal Councils, GST Council, tribunals and Article 131 suits • The Inter-State Council meets rarely, and river tribunals are slow • Reforms include a permanent Council secretariat, a single water tribunal, technical panels and mediation

Q11 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Discuss the position of the Governor in the federal polity of India. What is the nature of his power while giving assent to a bill passed by the State Legislature? Is he bound by the aid and advice of his Council of Ministers in all his functions?

Federal Structure and Devolution

• The Governor is the nominal executive head of the State under Articles 153 to 159, appointed by the President and holding office during his pleasure • He links the Union and the State, which gives the office a federal role and a political edge • Article 200 lets him assent, withhold, return a non-money bill, or reserve it for the President • Assent is a constitutional duty guided by legality, not a personal veto, and bills cannot be left pending indefinitely • Recent Supreme Court rulings in the Tamil Nadu dispute and the later Presidential Reference tackled timelines and pocket veto • Article 163 makes aid and advice the rule, with discretion only in narrow express or situational areas • Shamsher Singh and Nabam Rebia limit discretion and make it reviewable • Sarkaria and Punchhi reforms on appointment, tenure and timelines remain relevant

Q14 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Examine the evolving pattern of Centre-State financial relations in the context of planned development in India. How far have the recent reforms impacted the fiscal federalism in India?

Federal Structure and Devolution

Finance Commissions devolve taxes; Planning Commission Plan grants created a discretionary second channel. Sarkaria and Punchhi criticised that discretion. NITI Aayog ended Plan cheques; 14th FC raised the States’ share of the divisible pool to 42%. GST shares tax but limits State rate power; cesses outside the pool and CSS keep Union leverage. Article 293 borrowing conditions remain a hard federal tool.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free