Q2 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2015 · GS II · 12 marks · 4 min read

← Q7 Q4 →

The concept of cooperative federalism has been increasingly emphasised in recent years. Highlight the drawbacks in the existing structure and extent to which cooperative federalism would answer the shortcomings.

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2015
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q2
Marks
12
Topic
Federal Structure and Devolution
Syllabus
Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.

Topic: Federal Structure and Devolution. Syllabus: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2015 and Federal Structure and Devolution.

Revision summary

India’s federal text is Union-heavy: lists, Article 356, All-India Services and tied schemes. Vertical fiscal imbalance and a weak Inter-State Council were core drawbacks of the old structure. NITI Aayog, 42 per cent devolution and a GST Council are the main cooperative answers of recent years. Cooperation eases planning and tax-sharing; it does not rewrite emergency power or the Governor. Forums need money and convention, or cooperative federalism stays a slogan.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

  • India is a Union of States with a strong Centre: a long Union List, All-India Services, and Article 356. In recent years the Union has named cooperative federalism as the method for GST, the Fourteenth Finance Commission, and NITI Aayog. Drawbacks in the old structure are real; cooperation answers some of them and leaves others in the text of the Constitution.

Body

Drawbacks in the existing structure

  • The Union List and the Concurrent List, with Union override under Article 254, let New Delhi occupy fields that States treat as their daily work: education, forests, and labour being the usual examples.
  • Centrally sponsored schemes, until recently designed in the Planning Commission, tied State budgets to Union guidelines and matching shares, so States spent on Union priorities rather than on their own Assembly mandate.
  • Article 356, even after S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), remains a political weapon; fiscal dominance through the Finance Commission grant conditions and GST architecture can also squeeze State autonomy without a formal emergency.
  • All-India Services, the Governor, and Union agencies in policing and investigation create a permanent Centre footprint inside the State executive.
  • Inter-State Council under Article 263 has met too rarely to be a working federal cabinet; disputes on rivers, migration and tax still go to politics or to the Supreme Court rather than to a standing cooperative forum.
  • Vertical fiscal imbalance is structural: States spend on health, education and law and order, while the most buoyant taxes were, until GST, designed and collected more easily at the Union level.

What cooperative federalism has begun to answer

  • Cooperative federalism means the Union and the States set shared goals and share money and data, instead of the Union commanding and the State complying.
  • Replacement of the Planning Commission by NITI Aayog (2015) was sold as a shift from plan-allocation hierarchy to a think-tank and a Chief Ministers’ forum; it can ease one-size plans if States actually sit in the Governing Council as equals.
  • The Fourteenth Finance Commission raised States’ share in the divisible pool to 42 per cent, which is a structural answer to vertical imbalance and gives Assemblies more untied money.
  • A dual GST with a GST Council is cooperative in design: States vote on rates and the Union cannot lightly ignore the Council if the constitutional amendment holds that bargain.
  • Inter-State Council revival, NITI working groups, and Disaster Management structures show that some Union–State work is now done in committees rather than only by ministry letters.

How far cooperation still falls short

  • NITI Aayog does not allocate plan funds as the Planning Commission did; without money, a forum can become a seminar, and States still face Union ministries on centrally sponsored schemes.
  • GST cooperation can freeze State tax experiments; compensation politics can recreate dependence in a new form.
  • Article 356, Governors, and All-India Services are not rewritten by a slogan of cooperation; they need convention and, where needed, statute.
  • River boards, police modernisation, and language issues still show competitive and even coercive federalism when party colours differ between Raisina Hill and the State capital.
  • Cooperative federalism therefore answers a good part of planning and tax-sharing drawbacks, and it does not by itself cure emergency powers, gubernatorial discretion, or Concurrent List occupancy.

What would make the answer fuller

  • Regular Inter-State Council meetings with published minutes, a permanent GST Council bargain that States trust, and fewer CSS strings on the 42 per cent devolution would match the rhetoric.
  • Punchhi and Sarkaria recommendations on the Governor and on Article 356 remain the unfinished federal homework.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

The existing structure is centralised in lists, money, services and emergency power. Cooperative federalism through NITI Aayog, higher Finance Commission devolution and a GST Council answers the planning and tax-share problems in part. It will answer the rest only when forums have money, the Governor is a constitutional figure, and Article 356 stays a last resort.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2025 · Q11 · GS II · 15 marks

    "Constitutional morality is the fulcrum which acts as an essential check upon the high functionaries and citizens alike…"In view of the above observation of the Supreme Court, explain the concept of constitutional morality and its application to ensure balance between judicial independence and judicial accountability in India.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q13 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

How far has the Indian federal framework been successful in accommodating regional and cultural diversities? Highlight the role of asymmetric federalism and suggest measures to make dispute resolution mechanisms more effective.

Federal Structure and Devolution

• Linguistic reorganisation from 1953 to 1966 gave regional identities an institutional home inside the Union • The Eighth Schedule now lists twenty-two languages and classical language status has widened • The Fifth and Sixth Schedules and Articles 371 to 371J create tailored autonomy for tribal and border regions • Friction continues in language policy, the 2019 changes in Jammu and Kashmir, Manipur and fiscal and delimitation concerns • Asymmetric federalism converts demands into negotiated settlements but needs funds and trust • Dispute machinery includes the Inter-State Council, Zonal Councils, GST Council, tribunals and Article 131 suits • The Inter-State Council meets rarely, and river tribunals are slow • Reforms include a permanent Council secretariat, a single water tribunal, technical panels and mediation

Q11 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Discuss the position of the Governor in the federal polity of India. What is the nature of his power while giving assent to a bill passed by the State Legislature? Is he bound by the aid and advice of his Council of Ministers in all his functions?

Federal Structure and Devolution

• The Governor is the nominal executive head of the State under Articles 153 to 159, appointed by the President and holding office during his pleasure • He links the Union and the State, which gives the office a federal role and a political edge • Article 200 lets him assent, withhold, return a non-money bill, or reserve it for the President • Assent is a constitutional duty guided by legality, not a personal veto, and bills cannot be left pending indefinitely • Recent Supreme Court rulings in the Tamil Nadu dispute and the later Presidential Reference tackled timelines and pocket veto • Article 163 makes aid and advice the rule, with discretion only in narrow express or situational areas • Shamsher Singh and Nabam Rebia limit discretion and make it reviewable • Sarkaria and Punchhi reforms on appointment, tenure and timelines remain relevant

Q14 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Examine the evolving pattern of Centre-State financial relations in the context of planned development in India. How far have the recent reforms impacted the fiscal federalism in India?

Federal Structure and Devolution

Finance Commissions devolve taxes; Planning Commission Plan grants created a discretionary second channel. Sarkaria and Punchhi criticised that discretion. NITI Aayog ended Plan cheques; 14th FC raised the States’ share of the divisible pool to 42%. GST shares tax but limits State rate power; cesses outside the pool and CSS keep Union leverage. Article 293 borrowing conditions remain a hard federal tool.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free