Revision summary
• Separatism and militancy reinforced each other, hurting lives and development. • Pre-2019 tools: security ops, packages, intermittent political outreach. • Article 370 gave temporary special status and conditional Union law application. • Article 35A privileged permanent residents on land and jobs. • August 2019: 370 effectively ended; 35A fell; Reorganisation Act created UTs. • Post: greater legal uniformity, new domicile framework, scheme extension. • Positive signals: investment/tourism push, grassroots elections, rights claims for excluded groups. • Caveats: security incidents, alienation and statehood debate continue.
Model answer
Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.
Introduction
Separatist politics in Jammu & Kashmir long supplied ideology, street mobilisation and, at times, overlap with militant networks that fed insecurity and stalled development. Successive governments answered with security operations, political dialogue and packages; the decisive constitutional break came on 5–6 August 2019 when the special status under Article 370 was effectively ended and Article 35A fell with it. Mainstreaming since then is judged by law extension, electoral revival, investment signalling and the still-hard task of healing alienation.
Body
Separatism, militancy and instability
Ideological and organisational overlap: Separatist platforms questioning accession created political cover and recruitment pools that militants exploited. Hartals, stone-pelting cycles and cross-border terror kept investment and tourism fragile for decades.
- Eg: Periods of intensified street unrest in the Kashmir Valley often coincided with spikes in infiltration and local recruitment—security and politics feeding each other.
Human and development cost: Civilians, security forces and migrant workers paid in lives; schools and businesses lost calendars to shutdowns. Instability was thus both a rights tragedy and an economic trap.
- Eg: Prolonged school closures during peak unrest years scarred learning outcomes for an entire student cohort in affected districts.
Actions toward the national mainstream
Security consolidation: Counter-terror operations, tighter financial scrutiny of overground workers, and border management aimed to shrink militant space. Decline in some violence indicators in later years is cited by official briefings—always verify the latest MHA figures before quoting.
- Eg: Targeted actions against terror financing and overground networks complemented kinetic operations against armed groups.
Political and administrative measures pre-2019: Autonomy talks, working groups, employment packages, PM's Reconstruction Plan-type investments, and intermittent coalition experiments sought to pull politics onto electoral turf. Results were mixed; separatist boycott calls often hollowed turnout in the Valley.
- Eg: UPA and NDA-era packages funded roads, power and skills, yet special-status politics continued to dominate identity debates.
Post-2019 constitutional and legal mainstreaming: Reorganisation into two Union Territories (J&K and Ladakh), extension of central laws, domicile redefinition processes, and local body/Assembly election pathways aimed to align rights and duties with the rest of India.
- Eg: Application of central legislation on corruption, RTI-type transparency norms and reservation frameworks was presented as equal citizenship practicality.
Development and connectivity push: Road and rail projects, medical colleges, tourism campaigns, and investment conferences sought a peace-through-prosperity narrative.
- Eg: Record tourist seasons advertised by the UT administration in some post-2019 years were used as proxy indicators of normalised movement—subject to security caveats.
Grassroots democracy: Conduct of District Development Council and subsequent Assembly electoral processes marked attempts to restore representative politics after prolonged central rule phases.
- Eg: High-security election logistics themselves became part of the mainstreaming claim—ballots against both bullets and boycotts.
Articles 370 and 35A — pre and post abrogation
Pre-abrogation Article 370: A temporary constitutional provision recognising J&K's special status: limited automatic application of Union laws; State Constituent Assembly-era arrangements; dual citizenship-type residency logic in practice through state laws. It structured a distinct legislative sphere for the erstwhile State.
- Eg: Many Central laws applied to J&K only via Presidential Orders under 370's mechanism, not by default.
Pre-abrogation Article 35A: Inserted via Presidential Order (1954), it empowered J&K to define "permanent residents" and restrict land, jobs and other rights to them. Non-residents faced barriers to property and scholarships that did not exist in other states in the same form.
- Eg: Critics called 35A discriminatory toward women marrying non-residents and toward Dalits/West Pakistani refugees awaiting equal status; defenders saw it as protecting demography and identity.
Abrogation process (August 2019): Using constitutional procedures involving Presidential orders and Parliament's endorsement, Article 370 was effectively denuded of operative special-status content; Article 35A ceased thereafter as it depended on that framework. The J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 bifurcated the State into UTs of J&K and Ladakh.
- Eg: 5–6 August 2019 parliamentary and presidential steps are the dated constitutional break every exam answer must pin.
Post-abrogation status: J&K residents are under the Constitution of India on the same general footing as other citizens regarding fundamental rights application; permanent-resident exclusivism of 35A no longer operates as before. Special security and UT administrative features remain; statehood restoration remains a political promise under debate.
- Eg: Land and job rules shifted to new domicile notifications under UT administration—details have evolved through subsequent orders that should be cited from the latest gazette if naming clauses.
Positive impacts on mainstreaming
Legal uniformity and rights expansion claims: Extension of central welfare schemes, reservation benefits, and rights legislation is presented as ending exceptionalism that blocked equal citizenship. Women and historically excluded groups gained from removal of 35A-type barriers—per government narrative and some civil analyses.
- Eg: Official communications stressed access to schemes and professional opportunities previously constrained by permanent-resident rules.
Investment and tourism signalling: Easier application of national corporate and labour frameworks, plus security improvements in phases, supported investment summits and tourist arrivals as mainstreaming metrics.
- Eg: Hospitality and film-shoot reopenings in the Valley were showcased as confidence markers—though militancy incidents did not drop to zero.
Electoral re-entry: Revival of grassroots and Assembly-level electoral contestation pulls youth toward parties and away from street veto politics—when turnout is real and campaigns are free enough.
- Eg: Competitive campaigning by national and regional parties in post-reorganisation polls is itself a mainstream political grammar.
Caveats for balance: Alienation, human-rights scrutiny of security measures, and statehood demands persist. Mainstreaming is unfinished if dignity and jobs lag flags and statutes. Positive impacts should be stated as directionally evidenced, not as utopia achieved.
- Eg: Separatist sentiment may retreat from open stages yet linger in private opinion—development must meet political listening.
Flow diagram
Conclusion
Separatist currents fed a long cycle of militancy and stalled normal life in J&K; governments answered with security, packages and, in 2019, constitutional abrogation of Articles 370 and 35A plus reorganisation. Pre-abrogation special status limited automatic Union law and privileged permanent residents; post-abrogation, the general Constitution and new domicile regime apply, with UT administration and ongoing statehood politics. Positive mainstreaming signs include legal uniformity, scheme access, investment/tourism pushes and electoral revival—still shadowed by security needs and trust deficits. The durable mainstream is ballots, jobs and equal rights felt in daily life, not only Gazette notifications.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
The Government of India recently stated that Left Wing Extremism (LWE) will be eliminated by 2026. What do you understand by LWE and how are the people affected by it? What measures have been taken by the government to eliminate LWE?
Next question on this syllabus topic (2025 · Q10). View answer →
-
What changed on 5–6 August 2019?
India ended the operative special status under Article 370; Article 35A fell with it; Parliament passed the Reorganisation Act creating the UTs of J&K and Ladakh.
-
What did Article 35A do?
It allowed J&K to define permanent residents and restrict land, jobs and related rights to them, creating a legal regime unlike other states.
-
What positive mainstreaming impacts are cited after abrogation?
Greater application of central laws and welfare schemes, new domicile rules opening opportunities for previously excluded groups, investment/tourism pushes, and revival of electoral politics—alongside continuing security and trust challenges.
Same topic · past papers
UPSC has asked this before
These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.
-
2015 · Q19 · GS III · 12 marks
The persisting drives of the government for development of large industries in backward areas have resulted in isolating the tribal population and the farmers who face multiple displacements. With Malkangiri and Naxalbari foci, discuss the corrective strategies needed to win the Left Wing Extremism (LWE) doctrine affected citizens back into mainstream of social and economic growth. -
2020 · Q13 · GS III · 15 marks
What are the major factors responsible for making rice-wheat system a success? In spite of this success how has this system become bane in India?
More from this topic
Q19 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS III · 15 marks · Solution
What are the major challenges to internal security and peace process in the North-Eastern States? Map the various peace accords and agreements initiated by the government in the past decade.
Internal Security and Extremism
The Northeast’s security problems mix leftover insurgency, ethnic conflict, drugs, migration and Myanmar-China borders. The 2020 Bodo Accord and 2021 Karbi Accord were the big Assam settlements of the decade. The 2015 Naga framework agreement is still not a final peace. The 2020 Bru-Reang deal and 2023 UNLF pact sit beside Manipur’s 2023 ethnic violence. Assam’s border agreements with Meghalaya and Arunachal tried to quiet inter-State maps.
Q10 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS III · 10 marks · Solution
The Government of India recently stated that Left Wing Extremism (LWE) will be eliminated by 2026. What do you understand by LWE and how are the people affected by it? What measures have been taken by the government to eliminate LWE?
Internal Security and Extremism
Left Wing Extremism in India means the Maoist insurgency centred on central Indian forest-tribal belts. Villagers suffer killings, extortion, closed schools and the crossfire of operations. Official figures show fewer severely affected districts and fewer deaths than at the peak. SAMADHAN combines intelligence, camps, surrenders and connectivity. A 2026 ‘end’ is credible as a shrinking map, not as the death of every idea; development and forest rights decide whether the map stays quiet.
Q20 · UPSC Mains 2023 · GS III · 15 marks · Solution
Give out the major sources of terror funding in India and efforts being made to curtail these sources. In the light of this, also discuss the aim and objective of the ' No Money for Terror [NMFT]' Conference recently held at New Delhi in November 2022.
Internal Security and Extremism
Major sources are overseas patronage, hawala, narcotics, counterfeit notes, extortion, misuse of non-profits, and emerging crypto rails. India uses UAPA, PMLA, NIA, FIU-IND, FCRA, narcotics and fake-currency drives, and FATF standards. The No Money for Terror conference in New Delhi in November 2022 was the third ministerial on terror finance. Its aim was joint investigation, freezing, and no safe haven for financiers, including new payment tech. International cooperation is required because the money chain is rarely inside one country.