Revision summary
Activists oppose AFSPA Section 3 (open-ended disturbed areas), Section 4 lethal force and warrantless search and arrest, and Section 6 sanction for prosecution. The Supreme Court in 1997 held the Act valid but subject to judicial review, minimum force, and prompt handover to police. Section 6 does not legalise murder or rape; abuse can still be tried if sanction is not a burial. Operational need can exist in a live insurgency; permanent, unreviewed AFSPA fails both rights and counter-insurgency legitimacy. Reform is time-bound maps, audited force, and fast sanction decisions.
Model answer
Flow diagram
flowchart TD S3[Section 3 disturbed area] --> S4[Section 4 fire search arrest] S4 --> S6[Section 6 Central sanction] S6 --> IMP[Impunity complaint] SC[Supreme Court 1997] --> VAL[Act valid] SC --> LIM[Review minimum force no abuse immunity] LIM --> NEED[Time-bound operational need only]
Conclusion
- Follow the 1997 guidelines in the field, not only in affidavits.
- Independent investigation of encounter deaths; fast yes-or-no on prosecution sanction.
- Review disturbed-area maps every six months in Parliament’s sight.
- Train troops in minimum force and in recording warnings, so Section 4(a) is not a street-execution clause in practice.
- Activists target Sections 3, 4(a)–(d), and especially 6: disturbed-area permanence, lethal force, warrantless search and arrest, and Central sanction. The Supreme Court upheld AFSPA but bound it to review, minimum force, and no immunity for abuse. The Act may still be required in a narrow, time-bound insurgency. It is not required as a permanent shield against the criminal law.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
Did the Supreme Court strike down AFSPA?
No. It held the Act valid in 1997 but said disturbed-area declarations and use of force can be reviewed and that abuse is not immune.
-
Is Section 6 a total pardon?
It delays and filters prosecution. The Court’s line is that it cannot be used as a prior pardon for crimes that are not bona fide official acts.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2015 · Q1 · GS III · 12 marks
The nature of economic growth in India in recent times is often described as a jobless growth. Do you agree with this view? Give arguments in favour of your answer. -
2015 · Q2 · GS III · 12 marks
Livestock rearing has a big potential for providing non- farm employment and income in rural areas. Discuss suggesting suitable measures to promote this sector in India. -
2015 · Q7 · GS III · 12 marks
Craze for gold in Indian has led to surge in import of gold in recent years and put pressure on balance of payments and external value of rupee. In view of this, examine the merits of Gold Monetization scheme. -
2015 · Q8 · GS III · 12 marks
"Success of make in India program depends on the success of Skill India programme and radical labour reforms." Discuss with logical arguments. -
2015 · Q10 · GS III · 12 marks
There is a clear acknowledgement that Special Economic Zones (SEZs) are a tool of industrial development, manufacturing and exports. Recognising this potential, the whole instrumentality of SEZs require augmentation. Discuss the issue plaguing the success of SEZs with respect to taxation, governing laws and administration. -
2015 · Q11 · GS III · 12 marks
What do you understand by "Standard Positioning System" and "Precision positioning system" in the GPS era? Discuss the advantage India perceives from its ambitious IRNSS programme employing just seven satellites. -
2015 · Q12 · GS III · 12 marks
What are the areas of prohibitive labour that can be sustainably managed by robots? Discuss the initiatives that can propel the research in premier research institutes for substantive and gainful innovation. -
2015 · Q13 · GS III · 12 marks
Discuss the advantage and security implication of cloud hosting of servers vis-a-vis in house machine based hosting for government business.
More from this topic
Q20 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS III · 15 marks
Why is maritime security vital to protect India's sea trade? Discuss maritime and coastal security challenges and the way forward.
Indian Economy
About nine-tenths of India’s trade volume and most oil still move by sea, so a chokepoint shock is an economic shock. Coastal creeks, 26/11-style gaps, illegal fishing, piracy and a denser Chinese naval presence are the main challenges. Red Sea attacks in 2023–24 showed how quickly freight and insurance can jump. SAGAR, IPOI, IMAC fusion, coastal police and partner patrols are the reply. Ports and shipbuilding make security a growth story, not only a patrol story.
Q16 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS III · 15 marks
India aims to become a semiconductor manufacturing hub. What are the challenges faced by the semiconductor industry in India? Mention the salient features of the India Semiconductor Mission.
Indian Economy
India designs many chips but still makes few, because fabs need capital, ultra-pure water, chemicals and restricted tools. Geopolitics and long project time add risk. The India Semiconductor Mission (2021) has about ₹76,000 crore for fabs, display, compound semiconductors and packaging. A design-linked incentive targets the talent India already has. Mature nodes and ATMP are the realistic near path; leading-edge logic will follow slowly if at all.
Q12 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS III · 15 marks
Discuss the rationale of the Production Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme. What are its achievements? In what way can the functioning and outcomes of the scheme be improved?
Indian Economy
PLI is a time-bound payment on extra sales to pull manufacturing scale into India. About fourteen sectors share an outlay near two lakh crore rupees. Mobile assembly and exports are the clearest win; value addition and several heavy sectors lag. Jobs exist mainly in assembly unless design and components deepen. Reform means easier claims, MSME access, export and value-addition metrics, and a sunset.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.