Q17 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · 8 min read

← Q1 Q3 →

Can the constitutional mandate of rights-based welfare be effectively realised in the context of non-integrated governance and minimal public investment? Examine.

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2026
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q17
Marks
15
Topic
Indian Constitution
Syllabus
Indian Constitution — historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.

Topic: Indian Constitution. Syllabus: Indian Constitution — historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2026 and Indian Constitution.

Revision summary

Rights-based welfare has a strong constitutional and statutory base, but silos across ministries and levels, low social-sector spending and rationed funds weaken delivery. DBT, mission-mode schemes, ration portability and district convergence help only when funding and local capacity grow with them.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

The Constitution promised a welfare state through Directive Principles, and Article 21, along with laws such as the RTE Act, NFSA and MGNREGA, has turned many of them into legal entitlements. The mandate can be realised only in part today. Departments, ministries and levels of government work in silos, and public spending on health and education remains low, so a right often exists in law but not in the village or the ward.

Body

Constitutional basis of rights-based welfare

From Directive Principles to enforceable claims: The Constitution placed welfare duties in Part IV as Directive Principles, which courts cannot enforce directly, but judicial reading of Article 21 and later legislation turned many of them into claims. The Supreme Court linked life with dignity, livelihood, food and education. Parliament then passed statutes that give a legal entitlement, a grievance route and a time limit. This shifts the citizen from a beneficiary of charity to a rights holder against the state.

  • Eg: Article 21A through the 86th Amendment of 2002 and the RTE Act 2009 made free education for ages six to fourteen a fundamental right, following Unnikrishnan v State of Andhra Pradesh (1993).

Statutory guarantees in food and work: The National Food Security Act 2013 covers up to 75 percent of rural and 50 percent of urban people with subsidised grain, and gives meals to children and pregnant women. MGNREGA 2005 promises 100 days of unskilled work on demand, with an unemployment allowance if work is not provided within 15 days. These laws are demand-driven and legally enforceable, which is unusual for welfare schemes. They show that rights-based design is possible in a low-income, large democracy.

  • Eg: PUCL v Union of India (2001) on the right to food led to cooked mid-day meals in all government primary schools, which later became PM POSHAN.

Welfare as citizenship: A rights framework changes the relationship between state and citizen because failure becomes an actionable wrong. A denied ration or unpaid wage can be taken to a grievance officer, social audit or court. It also forces the state to count who is entitled and to publish what was delivered. This builds the sense of equal membership that Part III and Part IV together intended.

  • Eg: Under MGNREGA, workers can claim compensation for delayed wages, and the Supreme Court in Swaraj Abhiyan v Union of India (2016) directed the Centre to ensure timely payment and drought relief.

How non-integrated governance dilutes the guarantee

Siloed ministries and schemes: Most outcomes that rights seek, such as child nutrition, depend on several departments acting together. Anganwadi services, health care, drinking water, sanitation and food supply sit under different ministries with separate budgets, targets and reporting formats. Each does its own task, and the child at the bottom gets partial help at best. Rights that need convergence fail when the administrative design divides responsibility.

  • Eg: Stunting in children under five stood at about 35 percent in NFHS-5 (2019-21), even though ICDS, NFSA, Swachh Bharat and Jal Jeevan work in the same villages, which points to weak convergence.

Centre, state and local layers: Education, health and social security fall mainly in the Concurrent and State Lists, while funds and design often come from the Centre. Local bodies were given functions in the Eleventh and Twelfth Schedules by the 73rd and 74th Amendments, but states have devolved few of them with funds and staff. When responsibility, money and accountability sit at different levels, each can blame the other for failure.

  • Eg: MGNREGA wage payments depend on fund release by the Centre and state agencies, and repeated delays have been reported, so a legal guarantee becomes unpredictable at the worksite.

Data and delivery fragmentation: Technology can improve targeting, but fragmented databases and rigid linking rules can exclude the people the laws were written for. Duplicate registries, mismatched names and poor connectivity lead to deletion or denial. Where grievance machinery is weak, exclusion errors turn into lost entitlements. A rights regime needs a person-centred delivery system with an easy correction route.

  • Eg: The 2023 mandate to pay MGNREGA wages through Aadhaar-based payment bridge led to large-scale deletions of job cards, and reports from Jharkhand in 2017 linked ration denial due to Aadhaar mismatch to starvation deaths.

Minimal public investment and the fiscal limit

Low public spending on social sectors: Rights need funds. Public expenditure on health has remained close to 2 percent of GDP against the National Health Policy 2017 goal of 2.5 percent, and public spending on education has stayed around 4 percent against the NEP 2020 goal of 6 percent that the Kothari Commission first proposed in 1966. Low spending means thin staff, unfilled posts, poor infrastructure and rationed access. A legal right on a small budget becomes a queue.

  • Eg: Many government schools and primary health centres report vacancies of teachers, doctors and nurses, so the entitlement exists on paper but the service cannot be offered at scale.

Out-of-pocket burden and quality gap: When public provision is thin, households pay from their own income, which pushes families into poverty after a single illness or a private school fee. National Health Accounts show that out-of-pocket spending still forms a large share of total health expenditure, though it has fallen in recent years. Insurance covers hospital stay but not outpatient care or the absence of primary services. The result is a rights framework that protects the better-off more than the poor.

  • Eg: Ayushman Bharat PM-JAY gives cover of ₹5 lakh per family, yet empanelled private hospitals are thin in many districts, and poorer states report lower utilisation.

Weak fiscal space and rationed entitlements: India's tax-to-GDP ratio is low for its income level, and states face FRBM limits, so welfare is sometimes capped by budget rather than by need. Wage rates under MGNREGA in many states stay below state minimum wages, and demand is rationed through delayed funds. A demand-driven law becomes supply-driven when money runs out in the middle of the year. This undermines the legal character of the guarantee.

  • Eg: Pending wage liabilities under MGNREGA often appear in the last quarter of the financial year, when states report exhausted labour budgets.

Can the mandate still be realised: ways to integrate and fund

Integration through technology and mission mode: Integrated design can reduce friction if it is built around the person. Direct Benefit Transfer cuts leakages, Jan Dhan accounts give access, and mission-mode programmes such as National Health Mission and Samagra Shiksha place several services under one plan. Portability and shared registries reduce paperwork. These tools work when grievance redress is strong and when they are not used to remove people from rolls.

  • Eg: One Nation One Ration Card lets migrant workers draw NFSA grain in any state, which was widely used during the 2020 lockdown.

Coordinated federalism and local capacity: Shared subjects require shared platforms. Inter-State Council, NITI Aayog's Aspirational Districts Programme and convergence plans at district level allow departments to plan jointly around outcomes. Devolving funds, functions and functionaries to panchayats and urban local bodies puts accountability near the user. District collectors and Gram Sabhas are well placed to run convergence if they have flexible funds.

  • Eg: The Aspirational Districts Programme tracks 112 districts on health, education and nutrition indicators and reported faster improvement in several of them through district-level coordination.

Fiscal commitment and a verdict: Coordination without money cannot deliver rights. Higher and predictable public investment, better tax mobilisation and targeted grants through Finance Commissions are needed. The Fifteenth Finance Commission recommended health grants through local bodies, showing that fiscal transfers can follow social priorities. Kerala, which spends more and has stronger local institutions, shows better health and education outcomes at similar income levels. The mandate can be realised only partly under the present setting, and fully only if integration and funding improve together.

  • Eg: Kerala's higher public spending, strong panchayats and primary health network give it infant mortality rates comparable with far richer countries.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

Rights-based welfare can be only partly realised when governance is fragmented and public spending is thin. The legal base is strong, and tools such as DBT, mission-mode programmes, ration portability and district convergence show that integration is possible. Without predictable funding, higher social-sector spending and devolution to local bodies, entitlements remain rationed. The way forward is to treat integration and fiscal commitment as one reform, so that every right has an office, a budget and a remedy.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2026 · Q18 · GS II · 15 marks

    Should education be treated primarily as a welfare obligation of the state or as a strategic investment for building a globally competitive, knowledge-driven nation? Critically evaluate.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q1 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 10 marks · Solution

Right to privacy relating to self-identity is very dear to every human being and well protected under Article 21 of the Constitution. In this context, examine the effect of the amendment in 2026 to the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.

Indian Constitution

• Gender identity is part of dignity, autonomy and privacy under Article 21, as held in NALSA and Puttaswamy. • The 2019 Act already weakened self-identification through the District Magistrate certificate route. • An amendment that adds medical or board scrutiny turns a right into a permission. • Collecting medical history creates data risks and fails the proportionality test when gentler options exist. • Intersex variation and gender identity are different and should not sit under one test. • Remedies are weak without strong penalties, reservation and working institutions. • A fair design keeps self-declaration, confidential records, time limits and community participation.

Q3 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 10 marks · Solution

Compare and contrast the President's power to pardon in India and in the USA. Are there any limits to it in both the countries? What are 'preemptive pardons'?

Indian Constitution

Article 72 (and 161) are exercised on aid and advice; Maru Ram, Kehar Singh, Epuru Sudhakar and Shatrughan Chauhan frame Indian limits and delay. The US Article II pardon is personal, federal-only, and barred in impeachment. Judicial review is stronger in India; political cost is the main US brake. A preemptive pardon forgives before conviction, as in Ford–Nixon. India has no working doctrine of preemptive pardon for the untried.

Q15 · UPSC Mains 2024 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Discuss India as a secular state and compare with the secular principles of the US constitution.

Indian Constitution

Indian secularism: Preamble, Articles 25–28, Bommai as basic structure, personal laws, State reform of Hindu law and regulation of temples. US secularism: First Amendment establishment and free exercise, Everson’s wall, Engel on school prayer, no millet personal law. India practises principled distance and social reform; the United States practises non-establishment. Minority educational rights under Article 30 have no US analogue of that form. Neither wall nor distance is a finished peace with majoritarian politics. Comparison is of method, not of piety.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free