Revision summary
The quote names a split: knowledge at the bottom, decisions at the top, execution in between. CSS, SPVs and parallel bodies bypass 73rd/74th institutions that the Constitution empowered. 2nd ARC and Punchhi already diagnosed fragmentation of the local State. The critique fits toilets, housing and MGNREGA planning; it fits less for vaccines, tax and defence. Repair: subsidiarity, untied local finance, elected control of SPVs, shared MIS with the Gram Sabha.
Model answer
Introduction
Development works when the person who knows the field can decide and do. The quoted models do the opposite: a mission in Delhi designs a toilet, a dashboard in a secretariat scores it, and a contractual worker in the hamlet discovers that the pit hits rock. Information lives below. Authority lives above. Execution is asked to obey both and satisfies neither.
Body
The displacement of decision
Centrally Sponsored Schemes write unit costs and guidelines for a continent. Smart City SPVs, societies and project-management units bypass the municipality that holds the drain map. Parallel self-help and contractor chains bypass the Gram Panchayat that holds the job card list. 2nd ARC called this the fragmentation of the local State. Punchhi asked for a reduction of CSS. 73rd and 74th Amendments tried to put the 11th and 12th Schedules where the information is. Activity maps were notified and then starved of staff and untied money.
A district collector still signs what a ward member cannot. That is not always tyranny; it is often the only office that exists. The critique still holds: NITI dashboards can punish a State for a definition that the village never saw.
Critical evaluation
The quote is largely true for livelihoods, local water, housing typologies and school language. PM-JANMAN will fail if PVTG housing is a standard Delhi packet. MGNREGA works better where the Gram Sabha plans the shelf of works — the original design — and worse where a software-only demand is uploaded from town.
It is not always true for immunisation cold chains, tax bases, defence, and macro-stability. Some information is national (a virus, a bond market). GST cannot be set in every taluk. The error is to treat every development problem as a national mission with a photo-op.
- COVID-19 showed both: ICMR and the Union ran tests and vaccines; municipal tracing and panchayat isolation centres succeeded where they were trusted. Kerala’s local governments and some eastern panchayats used proximity; others waited for a portal.
Repair
Subsidiarity: default to the lowest competent tier. Untied 15th FC local grants were a start. Activity mapping with officers (not only functions on paper). Kill parallel SPVs or put them under the elected council. Let the Gram Sabha see the same MIS the secretary sees. Central standards can remain for rights and minimums (food, cash floor, school years); design and procurement should sit near the soil.
The objectives of development — capability, voice, a usable asset — are defeated when the file cannot hear the well.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD I[Local information] --> X[Should decide] D[Delhi mission] --> E[Execution] I -.->|broken link| D P[73 74 FC grants] --> I
Conclusion
When decision, knowledge and work are split across Delhi, the district and a contractor, development becomes compliance. The 73rd and 74th Amendments named the repair. Missions and SPVs have often undone it. Keep national minima; return design to the place that holds the information.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights has to address the challenges faced by children in the digital era. Examine the existing policies and suggest measures the Commission can initiate to tackle the issue.
Next question on this syllabus topic (2025 · Q18). View answer →
-
Should every scheme be fully local?
No. Rights floors and inter-State spillovers can be national. House design and pond siting should not be.
-
Are collectors the problem?
Collectors exist because local governments were not staffed. Strengthening the latter is the constitutional path, not romanticising the former.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2025 · Q2 · GS II · 10 marks
Comment on the need of administrative tribunals as compared to the court system. Assess the impact of the recent tribunal reforms through rationalization of tribunals made in 2021. -
2025 · Q4 · GS II · 10 marks
Discuss the nature of Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly after the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Act, 2019. Briefly describe the powers and functions of the Assembly of the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir. -
2025 · Q6 · GS II · 10 marks
Women's social capital complements in advancing empowerment and gender equity. Explain. -
2025 · Q10 · GS II · 10 marks
"With the waning of globalization, post-Cold War world is becoming a site of sovereign nationalism." Elucidate. -
2025 · Q15 · GS II · 15 marks
What are environmental pressure groups? Discuss their role in raising awareness, influencing policies and advocating for environmental protection in India. -
2025 · Q18 · GS II · 15 marks
The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights has to address the challenges faced by children in the digital era. Examine the existing policies and suggest measures the Commission can initiate to tackle the issue. -
2024 · Q4 · GS II · 10 marks
"The duty of the Comptroller and Auditor General is not merely to ensure the legality of expenditure but also its propriety." Comment. -
2024 · Q5 · GS II · 10 marks
Analyse the role of local bodies in providing good governance at local level and bring out the pros and cons of merging the rural local bodies with the urban local bodies.
More from this topic
Q18 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks
The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights has to address the challenges faced by children in the digital era. Examine the existing policies and suggest measures the Commission can initiate to tackle the issue.
Governance and Policy
Harms: grooming, bullying, addictive design, data profiling, deepfakes, influencer labour, and exclusion without devices. Law: POCSO, IT rules, JJ Act, DPDP 2023 parental consent, NEP caution on ed-tech. NCPCR can inquire, recommend and move courts under the 2005 Act. Measures: age-assurance, school device rules with offline equity, POCSO e-evidence protocol, ed-tech data audits, 1098 integration, influencer-work codes, privacy-by-default for minors. The Commission should regulate design, not become a meme censor.
Q15 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 15 marks
What are environmental pressure groups? Discuss their role in raising awareness, influencing policies and advocating for environmental protection in India.
Governance and Policy
Environmental pressure groups organise to change ecological decisions of State and firms. Awareness: Chipko, Silent Valley, CSE and climate networks. Policy: EPA, FRA, NGT, EIA contests, PESA and mining consent. Advocacy: Mehta cases, Godavarman, Niyamgiri, Narmada and later climate-rights litigation. Limits: urban bias versus FRA communities, science errors, FCRA chill; they are one constitutional voice, not the ministry.
Q10 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 10 marks
"With the waning of globalization, post-Cold War world is becoming a site of sovereign nationalism." Elucidate.
Governance and Policy
Post-Cold War hyper-globalisation has waned: WTO strain, export controls, vaccine nationalism, and war. Sovereign nationalism is industrial policy, data and energy security, and minilateral clubs of States. Interdependence continues under political licence, not as a religion of efficiency. India’s PLI, strategic oil and DPI diplomacy sit inside this shift. Climate and pandemics still require more than one flag.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.