Q12 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2021 · GS II · 15 marks · 3 min read

← Q5 Q16 →

Though the Human Rights Commissions have contributed immensely to the protection of human rights in India, yet they have failed to assert themselves against the mighty and powerful. Analyzing their structural and practical limitations, suggest remedial measures.

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2021
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q12
Marks
15
Topic
Governance and Policy
Syllabus
Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation.

Topic: Governance and Policy. Syllabus: Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2021 and Governance and Policy.

Revision summary

NHRC and State Commissions have documented custodial harm, bonded labour and prison conditions, and recommended relief. The Protection of Human Rights Act keeps them largely recommendatory and often dependent on borrowed police. Armed-forces procedure, one-year limitation, vacancies and political appointments blunt action against the powerful. The 2019 amendment widened membership but did not create enforcement teeth. Remedies: time-bound implementation of core findings, a civilian investigation wing, charged finances, diversity, and Paris Principles independence.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

The National Human Rights Commission and the State Commissions have given India a standing address for custodial violence, bonded labour, and delay in rights cases. The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, however, built them as recommendatory bodies. Against the mighty — police leadership, armed forces, and sitting executives — that design often fails to assert.

Body

Contribution that is real

  • NHRC fact-finding, spot inquiries, and compensation recommendations have made custodial deaths and encounter killings harder to bury in a district file.
  • Interventions on bonded labour, mental hospitals, and prison overcrowding created a public record that courts and the press could use.
  • State Human Rights Commissions, where they function, shorten the distance for a poor complainant who will never reach New Delhi.
  • Paris Principles-style publicity and annual reports have kept human rights inside the official vocabulary even when governments are impatient.

Structural limitations in the Act

  • The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 (amended 2006 and 2019) makes NHRC recommendations non-binding; a powerful ministry can note, delay, or dilute them.
  • Investigation often depends on police on deputation, so the Commission is structurally shy of indicting the force that staffs it.
  • Section 19-type limits on the armed forces — a report-seeking procedure rather than a full independent probe — weaken the Commission precisely where State violence is most insulated.
  • The 2019 amendment widened the pool for chairperson and members (no longer only a former Chief Justice of India as chair) and allowed persons from other fields; critics said this could dilute judicial weight even as vacancies were the older disease.
  • Jurisdiction over cases older than one year, and a crowded cause list, shut out slow-burning violations that the powerful prefer to wait out.

Practical limitations against the mighty

  • Delayed appointments, acting chairs, and understaffed State Commissions make the institution look optional to a Chief Minister or a Union Home ministry.
  • Political appointees and post-retirement incentives can blunt inquiry into the government of the day.
  • Complainants against large corporations, security laws, or ruling-party cadres face the same recommendatory ceiling: shame without sanction.
  • Poor coordination with the National Commission for Women, SC/ST commissions, and the courts produces forum-shopping and dropped files.

Remedial measures

  • Give selected NHRC findings — custodial death, proven torture, wilful non-cooperation — a statutory duty to implement within a fixed time, subject to judicial review, so the mighty face more than a letter.
  • Build an independent investigation wing of forensic and civilian investigators, not only borrowed police.
  • Align the armed-forces procedure with a time-bound, reasoned public order, and let the Commission approach the Supreme Court as of right when the Union stonewalls.
  • Fix a six-month rule for filling vacancies, gender and minority diversity on the bench, and financial charge on the Consolidated Fund to protect the budget.
  • Recommendation: Paris Principles compliance in law, not only in the annual report — independence of appointment, own investigative capacity, and enforceable follow-up.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

Human Rights Commissions have contributed immensely as recorders, visitors, and recommenders. They fail against the mighty because the Protection of Human Rights Act left them recommendatory, police-dependent, and weak on the armed forces, while practice added vacancies and political timing. Remedies are statutory bite, an independent probe wing, time-bound appointments, and court-backed enforcement — assertion by design, not by the courage of a particular chair.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2018 · Q16 · GS II · 15 marks

    Multiplicity of various commissions for the vulnerable sections of the society leads to problems of overlapping jurisdiction and duplication of functions. Is it better to merge all commissions into an umbrella Human Rights Commission? Argue your case. (15).

    View answer →

  2. 2018 · Q10 · GS II · 10 marks

    A number of outside powers have entrenched themselves in Central Asia, which is a zone of interest to India. Discuss the implications, in this context, of India's joining the Ashgabat Agreement, 2018.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q15 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

To what extent do pressure groups, social movements and corporate lobbies deepen pluralistic democracy in India by representing excluded interests? Analyse whether the growing convergence of corporate wealth and political power poses a threat to the autonomy of formal democratic institutions.

Governance and Policy

• Pluralism needs many competing groups so that no single interest dominates policy • Trade unions, farmer bodies and movements such as Chipko and Narmada Bachao Andolan have brought excluded voices into public debate • Movements delivered RTI, Forest Rights and Lokpal laws that give citizens lasting tools • Weak resources and FCRA and protest restrictions limit civil society reach • Corporate influence runs through party funding, lobbying, regulators and media ownership • The electoral bonds scheme was struck down in 2024 for violating citizens' right to information • Institutions such as the Supreme Court, CAG and the Election Commission still check capture, but risks remain • Reforms include funding transparency, a lobbying law, cooling-off periods and protection of dissent

Q12 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

What is meant by judicial legislation? In this context, discuss the verdicts of the apex court allowing "passive euthanasia" and a "living will".

Governance and Policy

• Judicial legislation is court-made law that fills a legislative vacuum, using Articles 32, 141 and 142 • Vishaka, Prakash Singh and NALSA are common examples, and each invited later legislation • Gian Kaur (1996) denied a right to die but spoke of dying with dignity when death is imminent • Aruna Shanbaug (2011) permitted passive euthanasia with High Court supervision • Common Cause (2018) held the right to die with dignity to be part of Article 21 and recognised living wills • The 2023 modification simplified attestation, board composition and timelines • The tension is between dignity under Article 21 and the legislature's domain on a sensitive moral issue • A national statute on terminal illness would replace interim court guidelines

Q6 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 10 marks · Solution

Does India's tribal development policy reflect the aspirations for a socially grounded and equity-based governance? Justify your answer.

Governance and Policy

• Constitution: Fifth and Sixth Schedules create tribal self-rule, with Tribes Advisory Councils and autonomous district councils. • Law: PESA 1996 makes the Gram Sabha central and FRA 2006 recognises individual and community forest rights. • Welfare: DAPST, Article 275(1) grants, Eklavya schools, PM JANMAN and the sickle cell mission target the gap. • Weakness: mining, dams and forest clearance rules often override Gram Sabha consent. • Weakness: delayed PESA rules, FRA claim rejections and diverted funds blunt equity. • Security: LWE districts show the cost of land alienation and weak service delivery. • Verdict: strong legal design, uneven delivery, so equity is partial and conditional. • Way ahead: enforce consent, social audit, benefit-sharing through District Mineral Foundations.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free