Revision summary
Frank: underdevelopment is produced by metropolitan linkage, not delayed take-off. This wrecks Rostow’s stages and names drain. Wallerstein generalised the insight. East Asian states and internal class limit a frozen satellite. Critique: keep linkage; reject one-fate delinking.
Model answer
Introduction
Andre Gunder Frank argued that satellite economies are made poor by their ties to metropolitan capitalism. Underdevelopment is produced, not a waiting room before take-off. The thesis hit modernisation theory. It also over-smoothed history.
Body
The claim
- Surplus is drained through colonial and neo-colonial trade. The core develops; the periphery is underdeveloped.
- Latin American cases were his field. Immanuel Wallerstein later widened this to a world-system.
What the critique gets right
- W. W. Rostow’s stages ignored empire. Frank made dependency a structure, not a culture of laziness.
- Indian deindustrialisation debates and later unequal terms of trade sit in this neighbourhood.
Limits
- Bill Warren and some Marxists said capitalism can still industrialise the periphery. East Asian developmental states challenge a frozen satellite.
- The thesis underplays internal class, caste, and the state, which Fernando Henrique Cardoso’s dependent development partly restored.
- Agency of peasants, unions, and postcolonial planning vanishes if only the metropole acts.
- Culture and gender are thin in the drain model.
Verdict
- Keep the production of poverty through linkage.
- Drop the implication that delinking is the only door and that all peripheries share one fate.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD CORE[Metropolis] --> DRAIN[Surplus drain] DRAIN --> UND[Underdevelopment] EA[East Asian paths] --> CRIT[Limits of freeze] INT[Internal class state] --> CRIT
Conclusion
Frank’s development of underdevelopment correctly attacked staged modernisation. Drain through the world market is real. East Asia, internal class, and postcolonial states show that satellites are not doomed copies. Use Frank as a warning, not as a complete map.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
How well do you think Tonnies, Durkheim, Weber and Marx predicted the character of Modern society ? Critique
Next question in the 2019 paper (Q5). View answer →
-
Did Frank deny any growth in the south?
He denied that such growth equals autonomous development. Enclaves can grow while the structure stays dependent.
-
Is 1991 India a refutation?
Liberalisation changed the mix. It did not erase hierarchical global production.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2023 · Q7(c) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Assess critically A. G. Frank's theory of development of underdevelopment'
More from this paper
Q1(a) · UPSC Mains 2019 · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Discuss the historical antecedents of the emergence of Sociology as a discipline
Sociology
Sociology emerged when industry, the state, and revolution made society a problem. Enlightenment comparison and Saint-Simon–Comte positivism supplied permission. Nisbet’s conservative themes of community and authority also fed the field. Marx, Durkheim, and Weber turned the name into a discipline. Census offices made method a public craft.
Q1(b) · UPSC Mains 2019 · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Davis and Moore made it clear that social stratification is a functional necessity and also an unconscious device. Discuss
Stratification and Mobility: Concepts
Davis and Moore: unequal rewards fill important roles; the device is unconscious. Tumin: importance is politically defined. Marx and Weber add exploitation, status, and party. Caste and gender close talent before sorting begins. Use the thesis for incentives; do not use it as a full theory of inequality.
Q1(c) · UPSC Mains 2019 · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
What is the Marxist concept of 'fetishism of commodities'?
Sociology
Fetishism of commodities: social relations among producers appear as relations among things. Exchange-value hides labour time as price. The illusion is socially real, not a personal superstition. Lukács extended it as reification. Gig pay and piece-rates still carry the appearance.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.