Are old-age homes un-Indian?

They are a modern institution. For the abandoned elderly they are a right, not a cultural insult.

Will more sons solve this?

Son preference already distorts childhood. Care policy cannot rest on more male children.

Q3(c) · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2015 · Sociology GS 2 · 15 marks · 1 min read

← Q1(c)

Discuss the problems of elderly in India. What are the different perspectives to solve their problems?\.

Topic: Tribal communities in India. Syllabus: Tribal communities in India: Definitional problems; Geographical spread; Colonial policies and tribes; Issues of integration and autonomy. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2015 and Tribal communities in India.

Revision summary

Open summary Close summary

Elderly problems include care gaps, poverty, widowhood, and health costs. Joint-family ideology no longer matches residence. Family-law, welfare, and market are the three solution perspectives. Widows and informal workers are the most exposed. Citizenship care must supplement, not only preach, filial duty.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

India’s elderly face thinning joint households, weak pensions, and health costs, while they are still imagined as family dependents. Problems are material and honour-based at once.

Body

Problems

Smaller households, migration, and widowhood leave many without co-resident sons, despite A. M. Shah’s warning not to equate household with care.
Poverty, informal work without retirement, and feminization of later-life poverty hit widows hardest.
Illness, isolation, and abuse sit beside the cultural claim that the ashrama of vanaprastha is honoured.

Perspectives on solutions

Familial: strengthen the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents Act and moral duty. This fits tradition-modernization, but fails migrants and the landless.
Welfare-state: pensions, Ayushman-type cover, and old-age homes as rights, closer to a citizenship view than to charity.
Community and market: SHGs, day-care, and private insurance, which split by class.

Sociological caution

Yogendra Singh would expect tradition to modernize into mixed care. Desai would ask who pays when surplus leaves the village.

Flow diagram

flowchart TD
  AG[Ageing] --> H[Household fission]
  AG --> I[Informal no pension]
  S[State pension health] --> R[Rights]
  F[Family duty] --> R

Conclusion

Elderly distress in India is the gap between kinship ideology and a mobile, informal economy. Solutions must mix enforceable family duty with public pension and health, or widows will carry the cost.

Quick related

Students also ask

Are old-age homes un-Indian?

They are a modern institution. For the abandoned elderly they are a right, not a cultural insult.
Will more sons solve this?

Son preference already distorts childhood. Care policy cannot rest on more male children.

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

2019 · Q8(a) · Sociology GS 2 · 20 marks
Why has 'Active aging' become a glocal goal? Do you agree that the role of elderly care-giving is disproportionately gendered in developing countries? Why?
View answer →