Q16 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2018 · GS III · 15 marks · 3 min read

← Q1 Q3 →

With growing energy needs should India keep on expanding its nuclear energy programme? Discuss the facts and fears associated with nuclear energy. (250 Words, 15 Marks).

Topic: Infrastructure. Syllabus: Infrastructure: Energy, Ports, Roads, Airports, Railways etc. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2018 and Infrastructure.

Revision summary

Nuclear offers low-carbon baseload and a thorium-based three-stage path after the NSG waiver eased fuel isolation. NPCIL’s operating record is a fact that supports careful expansion. Fears are accident risk after Fukushima, waste, high capital cost, liability, and local consent. Nuclear should grow as a limited share beside renewables and efficiency, not as the whole answer. Safety culture, an independent regulator, and honest waste plans are the conditions for any extra megawatt.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

India’s electricity demand will keep rising with industry, cooling, and transport. Nuclear power is a low-carbon, round-the-clock source that fits that need on paper. Facts on fuel, the three-stage programme, and import deals support a careful expansion. Fears after Fukushima, plus cost, land, liability, and waste, say it cannot be the only answer.

Body

Facts that support a nuclear programme

  • Coal still dominates Indian power and brings air pollution and carbon; nuclear adds baseload without daily smoke at the plant gate.
  • India has limited conventional uranium but large thorium in beach sands; the three-stage programme (pressurised heavy water reactors, then fast breeders, then thorium cycle) is the long scientific case for not abandoning nuclear.
  • NPCIL plants at Tarapur, Rawatbhata, Kalpakkam, Narora, Kakrapar, Kaiga, and Kudankulam have run for decades with a civilian safety record that, in published Indian data, is far from Chernobyl-scale disaster.
  • Civil nuclear cooperation after the 2008 NSG waiver opened imported fuel and reactor offers, which the old isolation had blocked.
  • Nuclear has a small land and fuel-transport footprint per unit of energy compared with many renewables when storage is counted, which matters for a dense country.
  • Lifetime capacity factor of a well-run reactor is high; it complements, rather than copies, solar that peaks in the day.

Fears and real limits

  • Fukushima (2011) showed that a rare natural event plus design and evacuation failure can destroy public trust; Indian coastal plants must treat tsunami and flood as design-basis, not as posters.
  • Radiation, waste, and decommissioning last longer than a political term; deep geologic disposal is still an unfinished global task, and India must be honest about interim storage.
  • Capital cost and time overruns make new large reactors expensive compared with solar-plus-storage on a short tariff comparison, even if night power is not the same product.
  • Land, fishing, and safety-zone protests (Koodankulam, Jaitapur, and other sites) are social facts; a plant that is lawful on paper can still be delayed into irrelevance.
  • Civil liability (Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act, 2010) and supplier worry slow foreign projects; this is a legal fear with investment effects.
  • Proliferation and security of fuel and plants need constant guarding; they are not reasons to stop, but they are reasons not to be casual.
  • Accidents are rare; fear is not rare, and democracy must budget for drills, independent regulation (AERB, and the long promise of a more independent statutory regulator), and transparent incident reporting.

Should expansion continue?

  • Yes, as a limited, high-safety share of the mix—not as a substitute for renewables, efficiency, and grid storage.
  • Prefer fleet PHWRs India already builds, complete PFBR learning, and add imported LWRs only where cost, liability, and local consent are honest.
  • Do not expand on soft coastal sites without independent hazard review.

Way forward

  • Publish emergency plans and waste routes in plain language; secrecy feeds fear more than spent fuel does.
  • Pair every nuclear rupee with renewable and efficiency rupees so the grid is not waiting for one delayed reactor.
  • Settle liability and indigenous supply so projects do not stall for a decade.
  • Keep IAEA-grade safety culture and an empowered regulator at arm’s length from the promoter.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

Growing energy need is a fact; nuclear can supply clean baseload and use India’s thorium science. Fears of accident, waste, cost, and consent are also facts, not only rumours. India should expand nuclear slowly, safely, and as one slice of the mix, not as a blank cheque against coal and solar.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2024 · Q12 · GS III · 15 marks

    What is the need for expanding the regional air connectivity in India? In this context, discuss the government's UDAN Scheme and its achievements.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q11 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS III · 15 marks · Solution

Explain the key challenges for India's energy security. What measures do you suggest for ensuring energy security along with economic growth and sustainability?

Infrastructure

• High oil/gas import dependence exposes India to price and supply shocks. • Coal remains baseload and jobs-heavy yet conflicts with climate goals. • Variable renewables need storage, transmission and demand response. • Critical minerals create new upstream vulnerabilities. • Affordability and clean cooking are part of security, not add-ons. • Measures: domestic hydrocarbons/nuclear/RE, storage+wires, efficiency. • Diplomacy, strategic reserves and mineral partnerships hedge geopolitics. • Just transition in coal belts keeps reform politically durable.

Q6 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS III · 10 marks · Solution

Differentiate between a Fast Breeder Reactor (FBR) and a thermal nuclear reactor. In the context of first indigenously developed prototype FBR at Kalpakkam, explain the term 'criticality'. What are its implications for clean energy future of our country?

Infrastructure

• Thermal reactors use moderators; FBRs use a fast neutron spectrum. • FBRs breed fissile fuel from fertile U-238 (and later thorium pathways). • PFBR is a 500 MWe sodium-cooled MOX prototype by IGCAR/BHAVINI. • Criticality = self-sustaining controlled chain reaction. • PFBR first criticality: 6 April 2026, 08:25 PM (DAE/PIB). • Criticality precedes full-power operation and further AERB steps. • Implications: uranium stretch, closed fuel cycle, thorium Stage 3 bridge, low-carbon baseload. • Sodium safety and regulatory discipline remain non-negotiable.

Q6 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS III · 10 marks · Solution

How can India achieve energy independence through clean technology by 2047? How can biotechnology play a crucial role in this endeavour?

Infrastructure

India still imports most of its crude, so 2047 independence means much lower import intensity, not a sealed border. Clean electricity from solar, wind, storage and nuclear, plus green hydrogen and efficiency, are the main path. Electric mobility cuts oil only if the grid is cleaner. Biotechnology helps through biogas, second-generation ethanol from residue, industrial enzymes and less energy-intensive farming. Fuel-from-food is a poor version of that biotech role.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free