Q6 · UPSC Civil Services Mains 2016 · GS II · 12 marks · 3 min read

← Q2 Q6 →

What was held in the Coelho case? In this context, can you say that judicial review is of key importance amongst the basic features of the Constitution?

Page facts
Exam
Union Public Service Commission — Civil Services Examination (UPSC)
Board
UPSC
Stage
Mains
Year
2016
Paper
UPSC Mains — General Studies Paper II (GS II)
Question
Q6
Marks
12
Topic
Indian Constitution
Syllabus
Indian Constitution — historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.

Topic: Indian Constitution. Syllabus: Indian Constitution — historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2016 and Indian Constitution.

Revision summary

I.R. Coelho held that laws inserted in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 can be struck down if they damage basic structure. Article 31B is not an absolute immunity from Part III and from judicial review. Kesavananda, Indira Gandhi, Minerva Mills and L. Chandra Kumar already treated judicial review as a basic feature. Coelho makes that feature the lock on the Ninth Schedule. Judicial review is therefore of key importance: it is how every other basic feature is actually defended.

Model answer

Copper italics in this answer — like this — are the key facts. Each one is unpacked in the Facts & figures rail.

Introduction

I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007) is the nine-judge ruling on whether a law put into the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 is immune from fundamental-rights review. The Court held that such laws can still be tested on the basic structure, especially if they damage judicial review or other identified features. In that setting, judicial review is not one optional tool among many; it is the feature that keeps every other basic feature enforceable.

Body

What Coelho held

  • The Ninth Schedule, read with Article 31B, was added by the First Amendment, 1951, to protect certain agrarian laws from being void under Part III.
  • Waman Rao had already drawn a line at 24 April 1973, the date of Kesavananda Bharati: laws inserted into the Ninth Schedule before that date had greater protection; later insertions did not get a blank cheque.
  • Coelho held that a law placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 is open to challenge if it violates basic structure, and that the Court will look at the actual effect of the law, not only at the label of the schedule.
  • If the law destroys or damages judicial review, equality, or other basic features, Article 31B cannot save it.
  • The judgment does not abolish the Ninth Schedule; it stops the Schedule from becoming a laundry bag that hides constitutional amendments and ordinary statutes from the Kesavananda test.

Judicial review among the basic features

  • Kesavananda Bharati (1973) listed judicial review, or the power of courts to examine laws, among the features that Article 368 cannot destroy.
  • Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain struck down the attempt to place the Prime Minister’s election beyond court scrutiny, which is judicial review applied to the electoral basic feature.
  • Minerva Mills (1980) restored the balance of Parts III and IV and treated limited amending power and judicial review as essential; clipping the Court’s power was itself unconstitutional.
  • L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997) held that judicial review by High Courts under Article 226 and by the Supreme Court under Article 32 is a basic feature, so even tribunal systems cannot oust that jurisdiction completely.
  • Coelho sits in this line: if Parliament could bury any statute in the Ninth Schedule, judicial review would be a paper feature, and basic structure would have no remedy.

Why it is of key importance

  • Federal distribution, fundamental rights, secularism, and free elections all need a forum that can void a contrary Act. Without judicial review those features are political appeals, not law.
  • Articles 13, 32, 136, 141, 142 and 226 are the working machinery; Coelho says Article 31B cannot switch that machinery off by a schedule entry.
  • Key importance does not mean judicial supremacy over every policy. It means that among basic features, review is the enforcement device. A feature that cannot be enforced is not basic in practice.
  • Later use of the Ninth Schedule has been cautious precisely because Coelho raised the cost of packing it.

Flow diagram

Flow diagram

Conclusion

Coelho held that post-1973 Ninth Schedule laws remain open to basic-structure review, including a direct attack on judicial review itself. In that context judicial review is of key importance among basic features, because it is the only feature that can police the others when Parliament uses Article 31B or Article 368. Without it, the basic-structure doctrine would be a sermon without a court.

Quick related

Students also ask

Same topic · past papers

UPSC has asked this before

These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.

  1. 2021 · Q14 · GS II · 15 marks

    Explain the constitutional provisions under which Legislative Councils are established. Review the working and current status of Legislative Councils with suitable illustrations.

    View answer →

More from this topic

Q17 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 15 marks · Solution

Can the constitutional mandate of rights-based welfare be effectively realised in the context of non-integrated governance and minimal public investment? Examine.

Indian Constitution

Rights-based welfare has a strong constitutional and statutory base, but silos across ministries and levels, low social-sector spending and rationed funds weaken delivery. DBT, mission-mode schemes, ration portability and district convergence help only when funding and local capacity grow with them.

Q1 · UPSC Mains 2026 · GS II · 10 marks · Solution

Right to privacy relating to self-identity is very dear to every human being and well protected under Article 21 of the Constitution. In this context, examine the effect of the amendment in 2026 to the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.

Indian Constitution

• Gender identity is part of dignity, autonomy and privacy under Article 21, as held in NALSA and Puttaswamy. • The 2019 Act already weakened self-identification through the District Magistrate certificate route. • An amendment that adds medical or board scrutiny turns a right into a permission. • Collecting medical history creates data risks and fails the proportionality test when gentler options exist. • Intersex variation and gender identity are different and should not sit under one test. • Remedies are weak without strong penalties, reservation and working institutions. • A fair design keeps self-declaration, confidential records, time limits and community participation.

Q3 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 10 marks · Solution

Compare and contrast the President's power to pardon in India and in the USA. Are there any limits to it in both the countries? What are 'preemptive pardons'?

Indian Constitution

Article 72 (and 161) are exercised on aid and advice; Maru Ram, Kehar Singh, Epuru Sudhakar and Shatrughan Chauhan frame Indian limits and delay. The US Article II pardon is personal, federal-only, and barred in impeachment. Judicial review is stronger in India; political cost is the main US brake. A preemptive pardon forgives before conviction, as in Ford–Nixon. India has no working doctrine of preemptive pardon for the untried.

PDF
Daily news · PIB · quiz — Free