Revision summary
NGOs in tribal areas are accused of blocking mines and missions of conversion. Some deserve critique as brokers or parallel patrons. Elwin and Panchsheel already valued non-official protection of land. FRA and PESA claims often need NGO paralegals. The test is whether the gram sabha is strengthened or replaced.
Model answer
Introduction
NGOs in the tribal heartland run schools, health, FRA help, and sometimes opposition to mines. The charge of interference mixes real failures with a wish to silence consent.
Body
The critique
- States and companies say NGOs delay roads, dams, and minerals and import a foreign agenda.
- Some outfits do run parallel patronage, poor accounts, or mission conversion that Ghurye would have called a rival assimilation.
- A few become gatekeepers of funds, reproducing the broker Bailey saw in village politics.
The other file
- Nehru’s Panchsheel and Elwin already wanted non-official friends of tribes against land grab. That is not interference; it is the ethic of consent.
- PESA and FRA need paralegal help because departments reject claims. NGOs often are that help.
- Fifth Schedule belts of Jharkhand, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh show mines arriving faster than titles. Critique of NGOs can be a critique of witnesses.
A balanced anthropology
- L. P. Vidyarthi would ask whether the NGO respects the nature–man–spirit complex or only a project log-frame.
- Useful NGOs translate; extractive NGOs replace the gram sabha.
- The developmental process itself is contested. Calling every objection interference assumes that the mine is development.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD N[NGOs] --> H[FRA PESA help] N --> B[Broker conversion] G[Gram sabha] --> T[Test of interference]
Conclusion
Some NGOs interfere as brokers or sects. Many others operationalise FRA and PESA. The fair test is gram sabha consent, not the comfort of the project authority.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
Are all tribal NGOs foreign-funded politics?
No. Many are local societies. Funding does not decide whether FRA help is legitimate.
-
Should development exclude NGOs?
The Constitution already includes gram sabha and TAC. NGOs are extra hands, not a substitute state.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2023 · Q7(b) · Anthropology GS 2 · 15 marks
Critically examine how the displacement of tribal communities due to hydroelectric river dam projects has affected the women in local context. Illustrate with suitable ethnographic examples. -
2022 · Q6(a) · Anthropology GS 2 · 20 marks
Discuss the objectives of Integrated Tribal Development Projects (ITDPs). How far have these objectives been achieved? -
2021 · Q6(a) · Anthropology GS 2 · 20 marks
Discuss the impact of the Forest Rights Act (2006) on the livelihood and culture of tribal people in India -
2021 · Q7(b) · Anthropology GS 2 · 15 marks
Discuss the problems involved in rehabilitation and resettlement of tribals displaced due to development projects in India
More from this topic
Q7(b) · UPSC Mains 2023 · Anthropology GS 2 · 15 marks
Critically examine how the displacement of tribal communities due to hydroelectric river dam projects has affected the women in local context. Illustrate with suitable ethnographic examples.
Developmental projects and their impact on tribal displacement and problems of rehabilitation. Development of forest policy and tribals. Impact of…
Hydro dams submerge the river commons that tribal women use for fish, fodder, fuel, and flood-recession farming. Compensation usually follows the male household head, so women lose title and natal networks. Baviskar and NBA work on Sardar Sarovar document Bhilala, Tadvi, and Vasava women’s losses and resistance. Lower Subansiri affects Mising and Arunachal hill women through flood pulse, safety, and labour camps. Polavaram, Hirakud, Tehri, and Mapithel show the same gendered pattern beyond one river.
Q6(a) · UPSC Mains 2022 · Anthropology GS 2 · 20 marks
Discuss the objectives of Integrated Tribal Development Projects (ITDPs). How far have these objectives been achieved?
Developmental projects and their impact on tribal displacement and problems of rehabilitation. Development of forest policy and tribals. Impact of…
ITDPs are Tribal Sub-Plan area projects, often called ITDAs. Objectives were integrated poverty reduction, services, and resource protection. Schools, roads, and clinics expanded in many blocks. Xaxa recorded leakage and weak control over land and mining. FRA and PESA had to carry the resource objective that projects missed.
Q7(b) · UPSC Mains 2021 · Anthropology GS 2 · 15 marks
Discuss the problems involved in rehabilitation and resettlement of tribals displaced due to development projects in India
Developmental projects and their impact on tribal displacement and problems of rehabilitation. Development of forest policy and tribals. Impact of…
Development displacement breaks tribal land, kin, and commons together. Sardar Sarovar on the Narmada is the teaching case. LARR 2013 lists land, house, and jobs; older 1894 awards were mostly cash. Colonies rarely restore nistar, council, or grove. Consent under PESA and FRA is the missing procedural core.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.