Revision summary
Harmful unexamined custom does suppress reason and becomes obscurantism. Child marriage, honour violence, and ritual humiliation are exhibits. Craft, grove, and care customs can hold empirical knowledge. Article 51A(h) asks for scientific temper, not cultural demolition. Stand: partial agreement, reform the closed custom, keep the arguable one.
Model answer
Introduction
Custom is inherited practice. Reason is public argument. When custom forbids evidence — witch hunts, child marriage, ritual humiliation — it becomes obscurantism. When custom carries diet, craft, and care, it is social memory. Agreement with the statement should be partial and sharp, not a war on all tradition.
Body
Where the charge holds
- Practices that punish questions — honour violence, khap bans on marriage, superstition as medicine — suppress reason and harm the body.
- Gendered custom has long blocked girls’ schooling and widow rights; reformers from Rammohan to Phule, Narayana Guru, and Ambedkar used reason and law against that obscurantism.
- Communal myth as history, and astrology as public policy, are tradition-talk used to avoid evidence.
Where the charge overreaches
- Not every custom is anti-reason. Panchayat water-sharing, sacred grove protection, and craft guilds can be empirical knowledge in another idiom.
- Blind modernism can itself be dogmatic. Scientific temper (Article 51A(h)) is a constitutional duty, not a licence to sneer at every festival.
- Living traditions reform from inside — bhakti critique, Sikh langar, Buddhist reason — which shows custom is not a sealed dark room.
How a republic should stand
- Agree that unexamined custom breeds obscurantism when it claims immunity from harm tests.
- Disagree that tradition as such is the enemy of reason. The enemy is authority that cannot be argued with.
- Tools: education, IPC and special laws against harmful practices, and reformers who speak the community’s language.
- Courts already balance Articles 25–26 with dignity and public order; that is reason disciplining custom without erasing religion.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD CU[Custom] --> H[Harmful unexamined] CU --> M[Memory craft care] H --> O[Obscurantism] RE[Reform education law] --> REASON[Public reason] M --> REASON
Conclusion
Agree that many customs have suppressed reason and produced obscurantism. Do not agree that tradition is only a darkener. Keep the practices that can face evidence; drop those that cannot. That is the constitutional middle.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
How have digital initiatives in India contributed to the functioning of the education system in the country? Elaborate your answer.
Next question in the 2020 paper (Q20). View answer →
-
Is all ritual obscurantist?
Ritual can be art and memory. It becomes obscurantism when it forbids evidence and inflicts harm.
-
Should the state abolish tradition?
The state should abolish harm. Communities should be free to keep non-harmful custom under the Constitution.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2020 · Q4 · GS I · 10 marks
Discuss the geophysical characteristics of Circum- Pacific Zone. -
2020 · Q12 · GS I · 15 marks
Persian literary sources of medieval India reflect the spirit of the age. Comment. -
2020 · Q16 · GS I · 15 marks
India has immense potential of solar energy though there are regional variations in its developments. Elaborate. -
2020 · Q20 · GS I · 15 marks
How have digital initiatives in India contributed to the functioning of the education system in the country? Elaborate your answer. -
2019 · Q3 · GS I · 10 marks
Examine the linkages between the nineteenth century's 'Indian Renaissance' and the emergence of national identity. -
2019 · Q4 · GS I · 10 marks
Assess the impact of global warming on the coral life system with examples. -
2019 · Q5 · GS I · 10 marks
Discuss the causes of depletion of mangroves and explain their importance in maintaining coastal ecology. -
2019 · Q14 · GS I · 15 marks
What is water stress? How and why does it differ regionally in India?
More from this paper
Q1 · UPSC Mains 2020 · GS I · 10 marks
The rock-cut architecture represents one of the most important sources of our knowledge of early Indian art and history. Discuss.
Indian Heritage and Culture
Rock-cut work survives as dated sculpture, painting, and inscription. Ajanta keeps Vakataka murals and Buddhist narrative. Ellora shows Buddhist, Hindu, and Jain patronage on one hill, including Kailasa. Mahabalipuram records Pallava rathas and the turn to structural temples. The caves are a core source, though they under-represent ordinary life.
Q2 · UPSC Mains 2020 · GS I · 10 marks
Pala period is the most significant phase in the history of Buddhism in India. Enumerate.
Indian Heritage and Culture
Pala kings endowed Nalanda and raised Vikramshila and related mahaviharas. The phase matured Mahayana and Vajrayana when much of India had other royal cults. Pala bronze and manuscript painting set an eastern Buddhist style. Atisha carried this learning into Tibet. It is the last organised Indian Buddhist university age.
Q3 · UPSC Mains 2020 · GS I · 10 marks
Evaluate the policies of Lord Curzon and their long term implications on the national movements.
The Freedom Struggle
Curzon pursued efficient empire: frontier, municipal control, and universities. The 1904 Universities Act tightened official grip on campuses. The 1905 Partition of Bengal triggered Swadeshi, boycott, and Extremist politics. Reunion in 1911 did not erase communal and revolutionary afterlives. Long term, Curzon expanded the national movement more than he pacified it.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.