Revision summary
Tylor: religion begins as animism, belief in spiritual beings from dreams and death. Müller: gods begin as linguistic personifications of natural forces, especially in the Veda. Both are intellectualist. Durkheim relocates the sacred in the group. Use them as a contrast pair, not as the last word.
Model answer
Introduction
E. B. Tylor and Max Müller both gave intellectualist accounts of religion’s origin. They disagreed on the first idea. Tylor started from the soul in dreams and death. Müller started from language and the naming of natural powers.
Body
Tylor: animism
- In Primitive Culture, religion is belief in spiritual beings.
- Dreams, trance, and death suggest a soul; the idea is extended to animals, plants, and the world.
- Survivals carry old belief into later stages. Evolution is from animism toward more abstract theism.
Müller: nature and speech
- Comparative philology of the Veda: gods arise as names of sun, dawn, and sky that language later personifies.
- Myth is a disease of language: forgotten metaphors become stories of beings.
- India and Indo-European comparison, not only a tribal isolate, are his archive.
Shared limit and Durkheim’s cut
- Both treat the first worshipper as a puzzled philosopher. Emile Durkheim answered that the sacred is social assembly, not a mistaken inference.
- Neither theorised church, caste priesthood, or gendered cult as power.
Comparison stated
- Origin: soul (Tylor) versus spoken nature-names (Müller).
- Method: ethnological survivals versus philology.
- Both remain useful as history of ideas, not as adequate sociologies of religion.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD TYL[Tylor animism soul] --> INT[Intellectualist origin] MUL[Muller language nature gods] --> INT DUR[Durkheim sacred social] --> CRIT[Critique of both]
Conclusion
Tylor’s animism and Müller’s nature-mythology are two intellectualist origins. They differ on soul versus language. Durkheim’s social sacred, and later Weberian meaning, overtake both as sociology, while the two still mark the Victorian debate.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
What is cult ? Explain the growth of cults in the contemporary world
Next question in the 2021 paper (Q5). View answer →
-
Did Müller study only India?
India and Indo-European philology were central. The claim was about language and nature more widely.
-
Is animism still used?
As Tylor’s evolutionary first stage, it is dated. As a label for spirit cosmologies, ethnography still uses it with care.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2021 · Q1(a) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Europe was the first and the only place where modernity emerged. Comment -
2021 · Q1(b) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Do you think ethnomethodology helps us in getting reliable and valid data ? Justify your answer -
2021 · Q1(c) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Discuss the challenges involved in collecting data through census method -
2021 · Q2(a) · Sociology GS 1 · 20 marks
From the viewpoint of growing importance of multidisciplinarity, how do you relate sociology to other social sciences ? -
2021 · Q2(b) · Sociology GS 1 · 20 marks
How far are sociologists justified in using positivist approach to understand social reality ? Explain with suitable illustrations -
2021 · Q2(c) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
How is sociology related to common sense ? -
2021 · Q3(c) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Do you agree with Max Weber's idea that bureaucracy has the potential to become an iron cage ? Justify your answer -
2021 · Q5(b) · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Critically examine the relevance of Vilfredo Pareto's theory of Circulation of Elites in the present scenario
More from this paper
Q1(a) · UPSC Mains 2021 · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Europe was the first and the only place where modernity emerged. Comment
Sociology
Modernity is a cluster of capitalism, state, science, and clock time. Europe was an early combination, as Weber, Marx, and Giddens show. “Only” ignores colonial modernity, Japan, and multiple modernities. Wallerstein places Europe inside a world-system. Comment: first is historical; only is false.
Q1(b) · UPSC Mains 2021 · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Do you think ethnomethodology helps us in getting reliable and valid data ? Justify your answer
Sociology
Garfinkel studies members’ methods, indexicality, and accountability. That can validate how categories are produced, including official ones. Reliability of national rates needs stable instruments such as Census and NFHS. Cicourel links ethnomethodology to the making of statistics. Justify: yes for interactional validity; no as a sole reliability design.
Q1(c) · UPSC Mains 2021 · Sociology GS 1 · 10 marks
Discuss the challenges involved in collecting data through census method
Sociology
A census seeks complete enumeration; coverage of migrants and the homeless is weak. Definitions of work and household threaten comparability. Trust, NPR-type list fears, and enumerator quality shape answers. Census 2011 stands; Census 2021 slipped in the pandemic. Official completeness is organised, not natural.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.