Revision summary
India's export growth after reforms was real, but the mix was more petroleum, engineering and chemicals than garments and leather. Rigid factory labour rules, costly land and power, and capital subsidies encouraged automation and small size. Bangladesh and Vietnam took buyer-driven apparel chains that hire many workers. Correctives are labour flexibility, the apparel and leather packages, MUDRA and clusters, GST refunds, Sagarmala, and skills tied to orders. The aim is jobs per unit of export, not only a larger export bill.
Model answer
Introduction
East Asia grew rich by exporting garments, shoes and simple assembly that hired large numbers of workers. India after 1991 expanded merchandise exports, but the mix tilted toward refined petroleum, engineering goods, chemicals and pharmaceuticals, which use more capital and skills per job. Labour-intensive lines stayed smaller than in Bangladesh or Vietnam. That is a failure of the employment engine, not only of the export total.
Body
Why labour-intensive exports lagged
- Labour regulation in the organised factory (hire-and-fire, contract labour, inspections) pushed firms to stay small or to automate, so they never reached the scale East Asian exporters used.
- Land, power and logistics costs are high; a garment cluster needs cheap sheds, reliable electricity and fast ports more than a capital-heavy refinery does.
- Skill and quality gaps in stitching, finishing and compliance with buyer codes kept India out of large global apparel chains.
- Policy often subsidised capital (cheap credit, tax holidays on plant) more visibly than wages, so the relative price of machines fell.
- Inverted duties, delayed refunds (before GST settled), and a strong rupee in some years hurt thin-margin labour exports more than high-value chemicals.
- China, then Vietnam and Bangladesh, took the buyer relationships in ready-made garments and leather while India specialised where it already had capital and engineers.
Measures for more labour-intensive exports
- Complete labour-law simplification for export units: easier fixed-term contracts, overtime flexibility, and one-stop compliance, as tried in some State reforms and special packages.
- Scale the 2016 apparel and made-ups package (rebate of state levies, overtime relief) and similar support for leather, footwear, gems and jewellery, and marine products.
- Use Make in India, MUDRA, and cluster and mega food park tools so MSMEs can meet volume without each unit buying heavy capital.
- Cut turnaround time at ports through Sagarmala, electronic trade facilitation, and full GST refunds so working capital is not trapped.
- Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana and apparel training centres should be tied to actual export orders, not only certificates.
- Coastal employment zones and plug-and-play sheds lower the land-and-power barrier that kills labour-intensive scale.
- Keep a competitive real exchange rate and avoid inverted duty structures that tax the labour-using input more than the finished good.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD L[Labour rules logistics capital bias] --> F[Capital-intensive export mix] M[Apparel leather packages] --> J[Labour-intensive exports] S[Skills GST refunds Sagarmala] --> J C[Clusters coastal sheds] --> J
Conclusion
India failed at labour-intensive exports because regulation, logistics and a capital-biased incentive mix made machines cheaper than large workforces. Apparel, leather and food packages, skills, GST refunds and coastal clusters can still shift the mix. The test is factory jobs in export sheds, not only a higher engineering-export number.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
Examine the developments of Airports in India through Joint Ventures under Public-Private Partnership(PPP) model. What are the challenges faced by the authorities in this regard.
Next question in the 2017 paper (Q3). View answer →
-
Did India fail at exports as a whole?
No. It failed at the labour-intensive mix. Capital- and skill-intensive goods grew faster than garments and leather.
-
Will more machines always cut jobs in exports?
Some automation is needed for quality. The problem is when policy makes capital far cheaper than hiring at scale in apparel and footwear.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2017 · Q1 · GS III · 10 marks
Among several factors for India's potential growth, savings rate is the most effective one. Do you agree? What are the other factors available for growth potential? -
2017 · Q6 · GS III · 10 marks
Stem cell therapy is gaining popularity in India to treat a wide variety of medical conditions including leukaemia, Thallessemia, damaged sornea and several burns. Describe briefly what stem cell therapy is and what advantages it has over other treatments? -
2017 · Q7 · GS III · 10 marks
India has achieved remarkable successes in unmanned space missions including the Chandrayaan and Mars Orbitter Mission, but has not ventured into manned space mission, both in terms of technology and logistics? Explain critically. -
2017 · Q16 · GS III · 15 marks
Give an account of the growth and development of nuclear science and technology in India. What is the advantage of fast breeder reactor programme in India? -
2017 · Q18 · GS III · 15 marks
On December 2004, tsumani brought havoc on 14 countries including India. Discuss the factors responsible for occurrence of Tsunami and its effects on life and economy. In the light of guidelines of NDMA (2010) describe the mechanisms for preparedness to reduce the risk during such events. -
2017 · Q19 · GS III · 15 marks
Mob violence is emerging as a serious law and order problem in India. By giving suitable examples, analyze the causes and consequences of such violence. -
2016 · Q1 · GS III · 12 marks
How globalization has led to the reduction of employment in the formal sector of the Indian economy? Is increased informalization detrimental to the development of the country? -
2016 · Q3 · GS III · 12 marks
Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) is necessary for bringing unbanked to the institutional finance fold. Do you agree with this for financial inclusion of the poor section of the Indian society? Give arguments to justify your opinion.
More from this paper
Q1 · UPSC Mains 2017 · GS III · 10 marks
Among several factors for India's potential growth, savings rate is the most effective one. Do you agree? What are the other factors available for growth potential?
Indian Economy
Savings finance investment and matter for potential growth, as in the Harrod-Domar link between the savings rate and output. India already saves a large share of GDP, mainly in households, so a higher rate is not the only or always the strongest lever. Idle gold and land savings, or a high incremental capital-output ratio, waste the savings effort. Other factors are investment quality, skills, infrastructure, institutions, technology and financial intermediation. Jan Dhan, pensions, GST, Make in India and transport programmes try to put savings to work.
Q3 · UPSC Mains 2017 · GS III · 10 marks
Examine the developments of Airports in India through Joint Ventures under Public-Private Partnership(PPP) model. What are the challenges faced by the authorities in this regard.
Infrastructure
AAI could not fund metro airport expansion alone, so PPP joint ventures were used for greenfield and brownfield hubs. Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Cochin show greenfield JVs; Delhi and Mumbai show brownfield OMDA with AAI equity. AERA regulates major-airport tariffs; later AAI rounds tried to PPP more State capitals. UDAN supports regional routes that do not attract the same private capital. Challenges are land, tariff disputes, high revenue-share bids, exclusive contract clauses, and weak PPP appetite for small airports.
Q4 · UPSC Mains 2017 · GS III · 10 marks
Explain various types of revolutions, took place in Agriculture after Independence in India. How these revolutions have helped in poverty alleviation and food security in India?
Crops, Irrigation and Marketing
The Green Revolution raised wheat and rice with seeds, water, fertiliser and procurement, ending ship-to-mouth cereal shortage. Operation Flood built cooperative milk; Blue, Yellow and Golden revolutions targeted fish, oilseeds and horticulture. PDS, FCI buffers and NFSA 2013 converted grain surplus into household cereal access. Dairy, fish and horticulture add protein, micronutrients and daily income that grain alone does not. Gains were regionally uneven; nutrition and rainfed poverty remain unfinished.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.