Revision summary
Culture follows dialect, food, and old country names more tightly than State borders. Bundelkhand, Bhojpuri country, Konkan, and Saurashtra are examples of mismatch. Linguistic States still concentrate a public language and cinema. Nested diversity means a State can contain many regions and a region can cross States. The fair view is that regions are the primary cultural units, States the political frame.
Model answer
Flow diagram
flowchart TD R[Historic regions] --> C[Speech food festival] ST[States] --> A[Law school official tongue] C --> D[Diversity] A --> D R -.->|often cross| ST
Conclusion
- Answer yes, with a caveat: regions are the finer cultural units; States are the legal frames that sometimes fit and often approximate those units.
- Use concrete belts, not a claim that States have no culture at all.
In India’s diversity, cultural units are more often historic-ecological regions than the State outline on a wall map. States matter for law and language policy, but they sit on top of Konkan, Bundelkhand, Mithila, and similar living regions that ignore those lines.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
What are the two major legal initiatives by the State since Independence addressing discrimination against Scheduled Tribes(STs)? (250 words).
Next question in the 2017 paper (Q10). View answer →
-
Does this mean States should be abolished?
No. The question is about cultural geography. States remain necessary units of government.
-
Are linguistic States failures?
They reduced some language conflict. They did not erase older sub-regions inside or across their borders.
PYQ trend
When UPSC asked this
Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.
-
2022 · Q8 · GS I · 10 marks
Explore and evaluate the impact of 'Work From Home' on family relationships. -
2022 · Q10 · GS I · 10 marks
Given the diversities among the tribal communities in India, in which specific contexts should they be considered as a single category? -
2021 · Q9 · GS I · 10 marks
Examine the uniqueness of tribal knowledge system when compared with mainstream knowledge and cultural systems. -
2021 · Q19 · GS I · 15 marks
What is Cryptocurrency? How does it affect global society? Has it been affecting Indian society also? -
2021 · Q20 · GS I · 15 marks
How does Indian society maintain continuity in traditional social values? Enumerate the changes taking place in it. -
2016 · Q10 · GS I · 12 marks
Why are the tribals in India referred to as 'the Scheduled Tribes'? Indicate the major provisions enshrined in the Constitution of India for their upliftment. -
2015 · Q8 · GS I · 12 marks
Describe any four cultural elements of diversity in India and rate their relative significance in building a national identity. -
2015 · Q11 · GS I · 12 marks
Discuss the changes in the trends of labour migration within and outside India in the last four decades.
More from this paper
Q1 · UPSC Mains 2017 · GS I · 10 marks
How do you justify the view that the level of excellence of the Gupta numismatic art is not at all noticeable in later times?
Indian Heritage and Culture
Gupta gold showed the king as archer, lyrist, or horseman with Lakshmi or ritual reverses and Brahmi verse. Metal was relatively pure and the die work was sculptural. Post-Gupta and early medieval coins often debased metal and used stiff stock types. Sultanate and Mughal art followed another visual language. The claim holds for Gupta-style numismatic art, not for all later mint skill.
Q2 · UPSC Mains 2017 · GS I · 10 marks
Clarify how mid-eighteenth century India was beset with the spectre of a fragmented polity.
World's Physical Geography
After 1707 the Mughal emperor lost the capacity to rule provinces in fact. Nadir Shah and Abdali exposed Delhi’s military hollowness. Bengal, Awadh, Hyderabad, Marathas, Sikhs, and Mysore became separate armed powers. Panipat 1761 showed even the Marathas were not a single state. Company victories in the Carnatic and Bengal fitted into this broken order.
Q3 · UPSC Mains 2017 · GS I · 10 marks
Why did the 'Moderates' failed to carry conviction with the nation about their proclaimed ideology and political goals by the end of the nineteenth century?
The Freedom Struggle
Moderate goals were council seats, ICS, and drain critique, not immediate independence. Methods were petitions and annual sessions that missed peasant and mill-hand life. The social base was presidency professionals speaking English public language. 1892 reforms were too small to prove the method worked. By the century’s end a hotter nationalist mood found them unconvincing.
Toppers' copies
Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.