Biological anthropology 62 / 79

Race as a failed biology — Boas, clines, India lists

Measure variation; refuse ranking. Indian ‘race’ schemes are colonial type-lists.

Race and variation — revision graphic for UPSC Anthropology
Race and variation — revision graphic for UPSC Anthropology

Critique

Why race fails as biology

Race is a social classification with a biological costume. Say that early; then give the measurements people misused.

  • Earnest Hooton’s typological race (shared looks, a ‘gene pool’) is a 20th-century museum label, not a subspecies.
  • Humans interbreed; isolation is regional and temporary — no stable subspecies cut.
  • Traits cline: skin, nose, hair vary continuously. Japanese once counted ‘white’, Chinese ‘coloured’ — the label follows politics.
  • Franz Boas: about 18,000 immigrant families; US-born children changed cephalic index — skull shape is plastic, not a racial soul.

Typological race

  • Types with essences
  • Hierarchy of worth
  • Census and empire

Population variation

  • Clines and gene flow
  • Plasticity (Boas)
  • Traits independently distributed

Key points

Old indexes — know them, then drop the ranking

  • Morphology: skin, eyes, hair (leiotrichous / cymotrichous / ulotrichous in the old lexicon).
  • Nasal index, cephalic index, dermatoglyphics (arch, loop, whorl) were ranking tools — now forensic/population hints at best.
  • Racist IQ ranking and Galtonian eugenics are the afterlife of the same tables.

India

India’s racial classifications — history of error

  • Risley: nasal index and caste as race — colonial administrative science.
  • B.S. Guha’s six-fold scheme (Negrito to Nordic) overplayed migration and a Negrito layer.
  • S.S. Sarkar’s six races (Australoid as earliest, and so on) — still a type list.
  • T.H. Eriksen: race and ethnicity both constructed; groups get racialised or ethnicised by power.
  • Exam close: quote the scheme if asked, then one sentence on why it is not biology.

WRAP Exams coaching notes for UPSC Anthropology optional. Pair with the official syllabus when you need every heading in order.

PDF