Revision summary
The CAG is a constitutional authority under Articles 148–151. Appointment is by the President; removal follows the Supreme Court judge process. Audit covers Union and State accounts and many publicly financed bodies under the 1971 Act. Reports go to the legislature and the Public Accounts Committee, not to a CAG court. The office does not pre-control every payment in the old Comptroller sense and cannot itself punish.
Model answer
Introduction
The Comptroller and Auditor General is a constitutional officer under Articles 148 to 151, charged with auditing Union and State accounts and reporting to the legislatures. The office is independent of the executive in tenure and removal, yet it is an auditor and adviser to the House, not a parallel government.
Body
Constitutional status
- The President appoints the CAG; removal is on the same grounds and in the same manner as a Supreme Court judge, which is the core of independence (Article 148).
- Salary and administrative expenses are charged on the Consolidated Fund, and service conditions cannot be varied to the incumbent’s disadvantage after appointment.
- The CAG takes an oath to uphold the Constitution; the office is not a ministry and not subject to day-to-day ministerial instruction on what to find.
Functions and reach
- Duties prescribed by Parliament (CAG’s DPC Act, 1971) cover audit of Union and State expenditure, receipts in specified cases, government companies, and autonomous bodies substantially financed by government.
- Reports are laid in Parliament or the State legislature (Article 151) and are examined by the Public Accounts Committee, which is how audit becomes political accountability.
- In India the “Comptroller” function of pre-sanctioning every payment, as in the historic UK sense, is not the working model; the office is essentially Auditor General with a constitutional name.
Limits
- The CAG cannot enforce a recovery or convict an officer; that remains with the executive, courts, and vigilance bodies.
- Policy wisdom is for the government; audit propriety can be contested as overreach when reports enter campaign season.
- Appointment by the executive without a statutory selection collegium is a live reform debate, even while removal protection is strong.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD P[President appoints] --> CAG[CAG Article 148] CAG --> A[Audit Union and States] A --> R[Article 151 report] R --> PAC[Public Accounts Committee]
Conclusion
The CAG’s constitutional position is that of an independent auditor of Union and State accounts, secured by judge-like removal and charged expenditure, reporting through Article 151 to the PAC. It is a watchdog with a report, not a second executive or a trial court.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
How will the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan affect India? Comment.
Next question in the 2018 paper (Q11). View answer →
-
Is the CAG a part of the Union Council of Ministers?
No. It is an independent constitutional office. Ministers do not instruct its audit findings.
-
Can the CAG prosecute a secretary for a loss?
No. It reports the loss. Prosecution or recovery is for the executive, investigating agencies, and the courts.
Same topic · past papers
UPPSC has asked this before
These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.
-
2025 · Q13 · UPGS2 · 12 marks
"The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India is the supreme authority of India's finance." Critically analyse his functions and position in the light of this statement. -
2021 · Q17 · UPGS2 · 12 marks
Examine the role of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) in India as the custodian of public money.
More from this paper
Q1 · UPSC Mains 2018 · UPGS2 · 8 marks · Solution
Why is India opposed to mediation on Kashmir?
Indian Constitution
India treats Jammu and Kashmir as an integral Union subject after accession in 1947. Simla 1972 and later bilateral texts require peaceful settlement without a mediator. Mediation would internationalise what New Delhi now frames as an internal constitutional and security issue. Pakistan is a counterpart for talks on terror and peace, not a co-sovereign over Indian territory. India therefore rejects UN, great-power, or other good-offices formulas that write a Kashmir settlement.
Q2 · UPSC Mains 2018 · UPGS2 · 8 marks · Solution
Critically examine the jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice.
India and its neighbours
The ICJ is the UN’s principal judicial organ under the Charter and the ICJ Statute. Contentious cases lie only between states and only with consent via special agreement, treaty, or optional clause. The Court rules on its own jurisdiction, as in Jadhav under the consular Optional Protocol. Advisory opinions go to authorised UN organs and are not binding judgments. Enforcement depends on states and the Security Council; individuals are not on trial at the ICJ.
Q3 · UPSC Mains 2018 · UPGS2 · 8 marks · Solution
Throw light on the challenges and problems of farmers and the agriculture sector in Uttar Pradesh. Suggest measures for improvement.
Social sector services
Uttar Pradesh leads in foodgrain output but farm incomes stay low on tiny holdings and uneven water. Eastern floods and Bundelkhand droughts sit beside western groundwater stress and cane-payment delays. Paddy–wheat lock-in and thin mandi–FPO reach keep farmers as price-takers. Remedies are last-mile irrigation, statutory cane dues, FPO and e-NAM markets, and a shift to pulses, millets, milk, and processing. Land-lease clarity and working crop insurance must travel with those measures.