Q5 · UPPSC PCS Mains 2023 · GS I · 8 marks · ~125 words in the hall · 2 min read

← Q4 Q6 →

'Unemployment is the only cause for the prevalent poverty in India' – Comment.

Topic: Women, population and associated issues. Syllabus: Role of Women in Society, women's organisations, population and associated issues, poverty and developmental issues, urbanisation, their problems and their remedies. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2023 and Women, population and associated issues.

Revision summary

Unemployment is a major cause of poverty, not the only cause. Disguised unemployment and informal work create the working poor. Land, health shocks, caste-gender gaps, and inflation also keep households poor. MGNREGA and skill policy attack jobs; NFSA, housing, and MPI attack other deprivations. The word ‘only’ in the statement should be rejected.

Model answer

Introduction

Poverty in India is low command over food, health, housing, and schooling. Unemployment is a major cause, but it is not the only cause, because many of the poor are already at work in low-productivity jobs.

Body

Why unemployment matters, but is not sole

  • Open unemployment, especially among the educated youth measured by PLFS, cuts household income directly and is a real driver of urban and graduate poverty.
  • Underemployment and disguised unemployment in agriculture keep families poor even when they are counted as workers, so the problem is often low earnings, not zero work.
  • Casual and informal work without contracts, seen in construction and petty trade, produces the working poor, which the statement cannot explain.

Other structural causes

  • Landlessness, tiny holdings, and rain-fed farming lock rural households into poverty even in years of labour demand, which is why drought and the 2015–16 farm stress years raised deprivation without a unique unemployment spike.
  • Health shocks, out-of-pocket hospital costs, and poor sanitation recreate poverty after a wage is earned; NFSA, 2013, and Ayushman Bharat address this layer, not only jobs.
  • Caste, gender, and regional gaps in assets and schooling, recorded in NFHS and NSS consumption, mean two workers need not escape poverty equally.
  • Inflation in food and rent can push households below a poverty line while employment stays unchanged.

Policy implication of the comment

  • MGNREGA, 2005, NRLM, skill missions, and PLFS-based employment targets attack joblessness and underwork.
  • Multidimensional Poverty Index work by NITI Aayog counts nutrition, housing, and cooking fuel, which would be redundant if unemployment were the only cause.

Flow diagram

flowchart TD
  U[Unemployment underwork] --> P[Poverty]
  L[Land health caste inflation] --> P
  W[Working poor informal] --> P

Conclusion

The statement is too narrow. Unemployment and underemployment are central, but land, health, caste, gender, and inflation also produce India’s prevalent poverty. A fair comment therefore rejects ‘only’ and keeps jobs as a necessary, not a sufficient, cure.

Quick related

Students also ask

  • Do you agree with the statement that crime against women in India is increasing?

    Next question in the 2023 paper (Q6). View answer →

  • If everyone had a job, would poverty end?

    Not by itself. Low-wage, informal, and unpaid family work can leave people poor. Assets, health, and prices still matter.

  • Is disguised unemployment the same as open unemployment?

    No. Open unemployment is no work. Disguised unemployment is surplus labour on a farm or in a shop whose removal would not cut output.

PYQ trend

When UPSC asked this

Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.

  1. 2024 · Q5 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

    Explain the contribution of women’s organisations in the development of Indian rural society.

    View answer →

  2. 2024 · Q9 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

    What is smart city? Describe its main characteristics.

    View answer →

  3. 2024 · Q15 · UPGS1 · 12 marks

    Discuss the causes and consequences of poverty.

    View answer →

  4. 2024 · Q17 · UPGS1 · 12 marks

    'Population explosion is a serious challenge to India's holistic development.' – Examine the statement.

    View answer →

  5. 2023 · Q6 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

    Do you agree with the statement that crime against women in India is increasing?

    View answer →

  6. 2023 · Q15 · UPGS1 · 12 marks

    Evaluate the role of woman organisations in woman empowerment.

    View answer →

  7. 2023 · Q16 · UPGS1 · 12 marks

    The process of urbanization leads to development or devastation in the society. Write your views.

    View answer →

  8. 2022 · Q4 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

    Discuss the causes of population explosion in India and give suggestions to combat this problem.

    View answer →

More from this paper

Q1 · UPSC Mains 2023 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

Give an account of the Vedic literature.

Indian culture

The four Vedas are Rig, Sama, Yajur, and Atharva, each with a Samhita core. Brahmanas explain the yajna; Aranyakas and early Upanishads move from ritual to atman-brahman. Vedangas are six auxiliary sciences that keep recitation and calendar. Itihasa-purana is Smriti and is not Vedic literature proper.

Q2 · UPSC Mains 2023 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

Write a note on the contribution of Sir Syed Ahmad Khan in modern education.

Modern Indian history

Sir Syed made modern education the core of Muslim recovery after 1857. The Scientific Society (1864) translated Western learning into Urdu. MAO College (1875) became AMU in 1920 and trained an English-educated elite. Tahzib-ul-Akhlaq and the 1886 Educational Conference spread the Aligarh programme. The limit is elite college education, not mass primary schooling.

Q3 · UPSC Mains 2023 · UPGS1 · 8 marks

Discuss the role of Sardar Patel in the unification of India after independence.

Post-independence consolidation

Patel and V.P. Menon used accession and standstill agreements to bring most princely states into the Union. Mergers created larger administrative units such as Saurashtra and Madhya Bharat. Junagadh was settled by takeover and a 1948 plebiscite; Hyderabad by Operation Polo in September 1948. Kashmir’s accession was a Cabinet file led with Nehru, not Patel alone. Privy purses and service integration completed a process Patel opened before his death in 1950.

Toppers' copies

Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.