Explanation
- A
10, 50
This option states the present ages are 10 for Seema and 50 for Laxmi. If Rahul will be 31 in four years, his present age is 31 minus 4, which equals 27. Since Rahul is 3 times as old as Seema, Seema's present age must be 27 divided by 3, which is 9, not 10. Therefore, this option fails the initial condition regarding Seema's age.
- B
9, 52
This option states the present ages are 9 for Seema and 52 for Laxmi. Rahul's present age is 27 (31 minus 4). Four years ago, Rahul's age was 27 minus 4, which equals 23. According to the problem, Laxmi was twice as old as Rahul four years ago, meaning Laxmi's age four years ago was 2 times 23, which is 46. Her present age would therefore be 46 plus 4, which equals 50, not 52. Thus, this option contains an incorrect age for Laxmi.
- C
9, 45
This option states the present ages are 9 for Seema and 45 for Laxmi. Rahul's present age is correctly derived as 27. Four years ago, Rahul was 23, so Laxmi was 46 (2 times 23) four years ago, making her present age 50. Since this option lists Laxmi's present age as 45, it is mathematically incorrect.
- D
9, 50
This option states the present ages are 9 for Seema and 50 for Laxmi. Rahul's present age is 31 minus 4 equals 27. Seema's present age is 27 divided by 3 equals 9. Four years ago, Rahul's age was 27 minus 4 equals 23, and Laxmi's age was twice that, 2 times 23 equals 46. Adding 4 years to 46 gives Laxmi's present age as 50. Both calculated ages match this option precisely, making it the correct key.
Summary. Official key is (d). Solving linear age word problems requires stepping backward and forward from a known future age to determine present values systematically.