Q10 · UPPSC PCS Mains 2018 · GS IV · 8 marks · ~125 words in the hall · 4 min read

← Q9 Q11 →

Recently you have taken charge as the head of a government organisation. On the very first day in your office, you observe that the organisation is crippled with many irregularities such as: (i) The staff is not punctual. (ii) The staff waste their time in unnecessary talks. (iii) Speedy action is not taken on public grievances. (iv) There is rampant corruption at every level in the organisation. (v) The quality of the services provided by the organisation is very poor. How would you inspire your staff so that these deficiencies of the organisation get removed? Discuss.

Topic: Probity in Governance. Syllabus: Probity in Governance — concept of public service, philosophical basis of governance and probity. Right to Information, codes of ethics, codes of conduct, citizens' charter, work culture, quality of service delivery. Challenges of corruption. Same official PYQ from year-wise 2018 and Probity in Governance.

Revision summary

First day: walk the counter, record facts, do not insult the whole cadre. Inspiration is example, a named citizen, staff voice, and peer pride — not a wall slogan. Punctuality and idle talk need a clock, an owned task, and a real break. Grievances need a visible date and a head who chairs disposal. Corruption needs sunlight, rotation, cover for the honest, then PCA. Quality needs a charter and tools that let staff succeed; systems must outlive the head.

Model answer

Introduction

The first day is a diagnosis, not a speech. The organisation is not short of rules; it is short of a will that the citizen is the principal. Inspiration here is not a slogan on the wall. It is example, fair process, sunlight, and a new map of honour so that staff choose a different day than the one you found.

Body

First-day ethic: see, record, do not humiliate the whole cadre

  • Walk the counter, the attendance, the grievance register, and one live file before any circular. Bandura’s staff will copy what the new head rewards, not what the joining speech praises.
  • Separate the willing from the ring: most delay is learned helplessness plus a few who sell the window. Inspiration fails if the first act is a mass insult that unites the office against the chair.
  • Put the five irregularities on one board as public facts, with dates, not as a moral sermon. People move when the problem is shared and specific.

How inspiration works (not only punishment)

  • Example: the head arrives first, sits at the grievance desk one hour a day, and refuses the first envelope in public silence — social learning of a new honour.
  • Meaning: tell the staff whose face they serve — a widow’s pension, a small trader’s licence — so idle talk has a rival story. Spirit of service is planted as a named person, not as ‘nation’.
  • Voice: a short, recorded meeting where clerks name the real blockers (broken software, missing peon, a tout at the gate). Inspiration includes being heard; Herzberg’s hygiene comes before a pep talk.
  • Peer pride: publish a weekly ‘closed with remedy’ list and name the desk, not only the defaulter. Reciprocity and Bandura’s vicarious reward beat a lone warning.

Mapping the five deficiencies

  • (i) Punctuality: biometric or a simple public register plus the head’s own clock; flex only where field work is real. Late-coming is often a cue that nobody is watching; watch without theatre, then apply Conduct Rules to the repeat, not to the first rain-day.
  • (ii) Idle talk: redesign the floor — a visible queue, timed windows, a canteen hour that is real so that gossip is not the only break. Idle talk is often a symptom of no owned task; give each person a named service and a number.
  • (iii) Grievances: a single visible clock, an acknowledgement with a date, a daily disposal meeting that the head chairs twice a week, and RTI-ready speaking orders. Speed is inspired when delay is no longer invisible.
  • (iv) Corruption: sunlight first — suo motu rates, a banned-tout board, e-payments, rotation of sensitive seats, and a safe complaint channel. Then PCA and vigilance for the ring, with protection for the honest clerk who was previously the bypass. Inspiration without teeth is a joke; teeth without cover for the honest is a purge that empties the office.
  • (v) Poor quality: a citizen charter with two measurable standards, a sample of files the head reads, and training that is a workshop on the actual form, not a hotel lecture. Quality rises when the staff can succeed; learned helplessness ends when the tool works.

Sequence and limits

  • Thirty days: example and sunlight; ninety days: rotation, charge sheets where evidence sits, and a celebration of clean disposal. Do not announce a war on day one without a file.
  • Inspire, then institutionalise: if the head’s charisma is the only glue, the old irregularities return on transfer. Second ARC’s systems — charter, appraisal that counts integrity, e-office — are how inspiration becomes the organisation’s memory.
  • Limits: a captured union or a political protector of the tout cannot be smiled away; document, escalate, recuse the desk, and keep the citizen’s window open through a camp if the building is sick.
  • Case-ready: the staff is inspired when the honest see a future, the lazy see a clock, and the corrupt see a risk — all three on the same Monday.

Flow diagram

flowchart TD
  E[Head example] --> I[Staff inspiration]
  S[Sunlight and charter] --> I
  V[Voice and fair teeth] --> I
  I --> R[Punctual clean service]

Conclusion

Inspiration in a crippled office is example, a named citizen, a voice for the willing, sunlight, and fair teeth. Punctuality, talk, grievances, corruption, and quality are one climate, not five separate circulars. The head who only sermons will be absorbed; the head who only punishes will be isolated. The head who makes a new honour inspectable can move the staff.

Quick related

Students also ask

  • Differentiate between ethics and morality and explain the determinants of ethical actions.

    Next question in the 2018 paper (Q11). View answer →

  • Should I suspend half the staff on the first day to show seriousness?

    No. Mass humiliation unites the office against you and may be unlawful. Record, isolate the ring with evidence, protect the honest, and let the first week be example plus sunlight.

  • If corruption is at every level, can inspiration work without transfers?

    Inspiration needs a new peer map. Rotate sensitive seats, bring a few clean hands, and open a camp window so the citizen is not hostage to the building. Inspiration without a changed group is a speech.

PYQ trend

When UPSC asked this

Related PYQs from other years, newest first. Open a question to read it.

  1. 2020 · Q2 · UPGS4 · 8 marks

    Discuss the role of the 'Right to Information' for transparency in governance.

    View answer →

  2. 2019 · Q3 · UPGS4 · 8 marks

    Write short notes on: (A) Ethical responsibilities of public servant. (B) Public interest and the right to information.

    View answer →

  3. 2019 · Q14 · UPGS4 · 12 marks

    What are the seven principles of public life? Are they codes of conduct for civil servants? Evaluate.

    View answer →

  4. 2019 · Q16 · UPGS4 · 12 marks

    It is often said that poverty leads to corruption. However, there are plenty of instances where affluent and powerful people indulge in corruption on a large scale. What are the main causes of corruption among people? Support your answer with examples.

    View answer →

  5. 2019 · Q20 · UPGS4 · 12 marks

    Meenu keeps telling her friends that she is fond of social service, yet she never participates in any social-welfare activities. One of her friend’s father is associated with an NGO that frequently organises welfare programmes such as free distribution of clothes and medicines to the poor. Although Meenu was asked many times to devote some time to that NGO, she showed no interest. What probable explanations can be given for Meenu’s conduct? Justify psychologically.

    View answer →

  6. 2018 · Q3 · UPGS4 · 8 marks

    What is the philosophical basis of probity in the governance? Discuss critically.

    View answer →

  7. 2018 · Q14 · UPGS4 · 12 marks

    What are the challenges of corruption? What steps should be taken according to you to prevent them from society? Explain.

    View answer →

  8. 2018 · Q20 · UPGS4 · 12 marks

    A Public Information Officer has received an application under the Right to Information (RTI) Act. After gathering the required information, he finds that the information pertains to some of the decisions taken by him, which were not totally correct. Some other employees were also a party to these decisions. Disclosure of the information may lead towards disciplinary action against him and his other colleagues including probable punishment. Non-disclosure of information or partial disclosure of information may result in less or no punishment. The Public Information Officer is an honest and conscientious person but the particular decision regarding which an application under the RTI Act was lodged was a wrong decision. The officer comes to you for your advice. Under the above conditions what will be your advice to the officer? Explain logically.

    View answer →

More from this paper

Q1 · UPSC Mains 2018 · UPGS4 · 8 marks

What are the values? Throw light over their central elements.

Civil Service aptitude and values

A value is a stable criterion of the worthy, not a passing mood or an unexamined habit. It differs from need and from law, though it must live with both. Central elements are stability, preferential ranking, cognition joined to affect, and a force that issues in conduct. Values are socially taught yet open to public reason, and they sit in a hierarchy when goods clash. A wall motto that never meets a file is not yet a value.

Q2 · UPSC Mains 2018 · UPGS4 · 8 marks

Define the ethical concerns in Government and Private Institutions.

Ethics and Human Interface

Government ethics is fiduciary: tax and force are not a private purse. Concerns are equality, neutrality, open files, conflict of interest, and the weakest user’s dignity. Private ethics is profit that must still justify wage, product, effluent, and books. Concerns are misselling, labour chains, capture, and data power. Both can lie; only the state owes the Constitution first.

Q3 · UPSC Mains 2018 · UPGS4 · 8 marks

What is the philosophical basis of probity in the governance? Discuss critically.

Probity in Governance

Probity is inspectable upright dealing, not a private glow. Its basis is trust (Locke, Gandhi), Kantian respect, Aristotelian and dharmic habit, Weberian impersonality, and Ambedkar’s constitutional morality. Critique: sermons fail without CVC, PCA, and a trail; rigor without equity can crush; virtue can be theatre; utility can excuse a bribe; dharma can become caste. The officer’s test is a speaking file under cost.

Toppers' copies

Toppers' copies for this question will be uploaded soon.