Revision summary
UP’s large farm sector limits the GST-era own-tax base. Petroleum VAT, liquor excise, stamps, and motor tax carry much of the residual State tax. Union devolution and the end of GST compensation create fiscal risk. Stamp, excise, and mining leakage plus weak local property tax cut collections. Salaries, pensions, and subsidies crowd out capital spending.
Model answer
Introduction
Uttar Pradesh must finance a huge population, a large bureaucracy, and expanding welfare from a still-narrow own-revenue base. The challenges are structural, not only a single year’s collection shortfall.
Body
Own-tax and base challenges
- A large agrarian economy stays mostly outside GST, so the State’s elastic own-tax base is thin relative to its size.
- After GST, remaining State pillars are mainly petroleum VAT, state excise on liquor, stamps and registration, and motor-vehicle tax—each politically or cyclically fragile.
- Property and local taxes remain under-collected; urban bases do not match urbanisation.
Centre dependence and GST
- Finance Commission devolution and Centrally sponsored schemes are large shares of the budget, so a slowdown in Union transfers or the end of GST compensation squeezes the State.
- Cesses kept outside the divisible pool reduce what Lucknow actually receives from national tax growth.
Administration and expenditure
- Leakage in stamps, excise, and mining royalties, plus a weak audit trail in some local bodies, erodes realised revenue.
- Salaries, pensions, interest, and subsidies consume a high committed share, leaving little for capital outlay even when headlines show higher GST.
Reform need
- Better valuation of property, digitised stamps, a stable excise regime, and wider GST compliance are the practical answers, not only new cesses.
Flow diagram
flowchart TD B[Narrow own-tax base] --> R[UP revenue stress] G[GST and Union transfers] --> R L[Leakage and weak locals] --> R E[Committed expenditure] --> R
Conclusion
UP’s revenue system is challenged by a narrow post-GST own-tax mix, high dependence on Delhi, leaky administration, and heavy committed spending. Widening the base and cutting leakage matter more than announcing new schemes on an empty till.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
Discuss the role of Civil Services in a democratic set-up with special reference to India.
Next question in the 2021 paper (Q11). View answer →
-
Is UP’s problem only that people do not pay GST?
No. Many livelihoods are outside GST by design, and remaining State taxes are leaky or politically hard to raise.
-
Would higher Central grants alone fix the system?
Grants ease a year; a durable fix needs a wider own base, better stamps and property tax, and control of committed spending.
Same topic · past papers
UPPSC has asked this before
These previous-year questions sit on the same topic. Open one to practise the earlier ask.
-
2024 · Q18 · UPGS2 · 12 marks
Examine the major issues of dispute between India and Bangladesh and give suggestions for improving bilateral relations. -
2020 · Q14 · UPGS2 · 12 marks
Identify the major pressure groups in Indian Politics and examine their role in it.
More from this paper
Q1 · UPSC Mains 2021 · UPGS2 · 8 marks · Solution
Discuss the role of Non-Government Organizations in the process of policy formulation.
Government policies for development
NGOs bring neglected social and environmental facts into the policy agenda. They feed research, model drafts, and working-group notes into design. Last-mile delivery and social audits return implementation failure to ministries. Litigation can force the state to rewrite guidelines. They cannot legislate; FCRA and capture remain limits on their role.
Q2 · UPSC Mains 2021 · UPGS2 · 8 marks · Solution
‘Citizen charter in India could not become effective. There is a need to make it effective and meaningful’ – Evaluate.
Indian Constitution
A citizen charter publishes service standards, timelines, and grievance routes. Most Indian charters stayed ineffective because they lacked staff, publicity, and penalty. Overlap with RTI and guarantee Acts reduced the charter to a poster. Statutory time limits, Sevottam-type quality, and compensation can make it meaningful. The evaluation agrees that reform must add sanction, not only a new document.
Q3 · UPSC Mains 2021 · UPGS2 · 8 marks · Solution
How are the issues related to hunger and poverty in India impinging upon electoral politics?
Policies of other countries
Parties treat food, work, and pensions as core manifesto goods for poor voters. Food and fuel inflation turns hunger into an anti-incumbency charge. Poverty geography influences tickets and caste–class coalitions. Ration and job delivery is sold as proof of a caring government. Identity and leadership still share the verdict; hunger is a major, not sole, driver.