Revision summary
India adopted parliamentary government but not parliamentary sovereignty — a written Constitution, fundamental rights, and federalism cap legislative power unlike the unwritten UK model.
Model answer
Introduction
The 2022 single essay probes why Dicey’s doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty does not transplant to India despite Westminster-style institutions.
Body
Vast but Limited Powers
- Scope: Parliament may legislate on Union and Concurrent subjects, control finance, amend Constitution (Article 368) — yet within constitutional bounds.
- Not sovereign: Constitution is supreme; judicial review under Article 13; distribution of powers with States.
Why Not British Counterpart
- UK: No written constitution; Parliament can theoretically enact any law; only political and international law checks.
- India: Written Constitution, justiciable FRs, independent judiciary, basic structure doctrine, Scheduled Areas protections, money bill procedures distinct.
Illustrations
- Striking down laws: Golaknath, Kesavananda, privacy (Puttaswamy) trim legislative absolutism.
- Federal limits: Cannot unilaterally alter State boundaries without parliamentary process but with Article 3 consent norms; GST Council shared sovereignty example.
Flow diagram
Conclusion
Indian Parliament is mighty within its domains but constitutionally conditioned — a deliberate departure from British sovereignty that preserves rights, federalism, and judicial guardianship.
Quick related
Students also ask
-
Discuss the problem of Centre-State relations in India and its prospects in future, with special reference to Bihar. Examine as to how the problem can be constructively handled in tune with cooperative federalism.
Next question on this syllabus topic (2022 · Q2). View answer →
-
Can Indian Parliament make any law like the UK Parliament?
No — constitutional text, federal lists, and judicial review restrict it.
-
What makes Indian sovereignty ‘limited’?
Supremacy of the Constitution rather than of Parliament alone.
More from this topic
Q8 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 36 marks · Solution
(a) In the perspective of the basics of cyber security, the need for digital sovereignty and the effectiveness of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), suggest components for a comprehensive internal security strategy. Or (b) “The New Indian Space Policy 2023 has opened the floodgates for the private sector.” Is this transition merely about technological development, or has it qualitatively transformed India’s capabilities for national security disaster response and border management? In the context of drone swarm technology, the security of satellite based communication and the strategic significance of GSLV program, propose the essential pillars of a comprehensive ‘Security-Development-Innovation’ strategy for India’s space and allied technologies.
General Studies II
India’s internal security and strategic posture increasingly depend on space-based C4ISR, private innovation under the 2023 Space Policy, and allied technologies (drones, secure satcom, GSLV-class lift) for disaster and border missions.
Q7 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 36 marks · Solution
Write short answer of the following questions: (See official booklet Section III short notes — cyber security / digital sovereignty / PMLA components and remaining short parts in media/pyq/2025/BPGS2-english.pdf.) In the perspective of the basics of cyber security, the need for digital sovereignty and the effectiveness of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), suggest components for a comprehensive internal security strategy. (Full short-note set: official PDF.)
General Studies II
Internal security in a digital age requires cyber resilience, sovereign control over critical data infrastructure, and anti-money-laundering architecture — PMLA being one pillar among intelligence, policing, and border coordination.
Q6 · UPSC Mains 2025 · GS II · 38 marks · Solution
(a) Discuss the major ports on eastern coast of India. Critically examine the role of Syama Prasad Mookerjee Port, Kolkata (SMPK) in the development of North East India and Bangladesh, giving suitable examples. Or (b) Describe the concept of fourth industrial revolution (Industry 4.0). Critically analyse the biggest benefits and risks of adopting industry 4.0 technologies in India.
General Studies II
Eastern seaboard ports anchor coal, container, and bulk trade for eastern India; SMPK (Kolkata) retains historic hinterland ties to North-East India and Bangladesh via river-sea multimodal networks despite draft limitations.